“…Unfortunately, there are no direct observations bearing on this question. But if the conclusion that there must be substantial high-frequency left-hand wave power at the sun does hold up under closer scrutiny, then it is Iikely that these waves must originate at the sun itself, since internal instabilities, such as heat-conduction-driven modes, can only be expected to become operable at least several solar radii above Ss, ergs nps, cm -s cm -'" s-• a the solar surface [Singer and Roxburgh, 1977]. [Hirshberg, 1973;Hirshberg et al, 1972aHirshberg et al, , 1974Hundhausen, 1970].…”