The Nusantara Capital City Project: Why Development and Human Rights Do Not Always Mix

Abstract

This article examines the Nusantara capital city project and its sociological impact on individuals and groups’ rights in the East Kalimantan regions of Penajam Paser Utara (PPU) and Kutai Kartanegara. The Nusantara Act was enacted to legalize the building of this mega-project and was finalized within a period of only 43 days. Thus, the legitimation of the Act is contentious. It is predicted that there will be widespread political, cultural, environmental and economic effects that will be likely to affect society in general and marginalized groups in particular. It raises two important questions, “what are the public rights that could potentially be breached by the Nusantara development project?” and “Is it possible to identify the influence of national and local elites on the process of promoting and legitimizing the Nusantara Act?” This article describes the concept of Nusantara as stipulated in the Act, which is linked to human rights values that are specifically related to the right to development. Based on the mentioned framework, this article finds evidence of autocratic practices in terms of the government’s efforts to acquire land for the project. It has been found that these dictatorial practices have been exacerbated by ‘cooperation’ with extractive industries and local elites. As a result, indigenous groups and the local communities in the area have suffered a loss of autonomy and land rights due to lack of legal protection within the Act.

Public Trust: Indonesian Policy in Developing a New Capital City (IKN)

“…as well as the development of a new capital city (IKN) in Kalimantan. During Jokowi's leadership, the IKN development plan began to be carried out seriously (Buana et al, 2022), which is different from the leadership period of Soekarno and Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, who also planned to build the IKN but failed VIVAnews, 2010). This old idea can only be realized gradually by Jokowi.…”

Waste management without direction in Indonesia: a proposed legal reform towards smart cities

“…The imbalance of obligations and responsibilities has an impact on the betrayal of the values of the welfare state adopted in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia (UUD NRI 1945) (Helander et al, 2022), where the state is not only obligated to ensure the security of the society but also actively participates in ensuring the well-being of its citizens through the formulation and implementation of welfare-oriented policies (Listiningrum, 2019a). Nevertheless, the Central Government and Local Government can be seen as transferring their obligations and responsibilities in waste management to the community even though the constitutional mandate clearly gives them the authority to ensure the fulfillment of the community's right to a good and healthy environment, which includes proper and environmentally conscious waste management as one of its concrete forms (Aspan & Yunus, 2019;Buana et al, 2023;Listiningrum et al, 2022;Ng, 2022;Nur, 2022;S. Singh, 2023).…”