The Nuclear Arms Race: Prisoner's Dilemma or Perceptual Dilemma?

Abstract

Traditionally, the most common game-theoretic model of the Soviet-US nuclear arms race has been an iterated Prisoner's Dilemma. According to such a model, on any given trial both superpowers are better off arming regardless of what the other side chooses, but if both sides arm the outcome is less desirable than had both sides reduced their supply of weapons. Although Soviet and US preferences resembled a Prisoner's Dilemma throughout much of the Cold War, recent evidence suggests that the arms race is now more accurately modeled by a 'Perceptual Dilemma'. In a Perceptual Dilemma, both sides: (1) prefer mutual arms reductions to all other outcomes; (2) want above all to avoid disarming while the other side arms; and (3) perceive the other side as preferring unilateral armament to all other outcomes. This article presents empirical evidence that the nuclear arms race is more appropriately modeled by a Perceptual Dilemma than by a Prisoner's Dilemma, including new survey data in which members of the Australian Parliament and the Israeli Knesset were asked to estimate the preferences of Soviet and US leaders. The paper concludes by reviewing several factors which sustain misperception and by suggesting that a Perceptual Dilemma can be solved with a clear, time-limited series of disarmament initiatives.A great deal in the development of relations between the USSR and the US depends on how each of the sides perceives the world.Mikhail Gorbachev, 22 November 1985

Good citizens to the end? It depends: Empathy and concern with future consequences moderate the impact of a short-term time horizon on organizational citizenship behaviors.

“…These parallels notwithstanding, it is useful to verify this basic assumption before proceeding to test social dilemma based predictions. Although researchers may generally agree that a certain decision reflects a social dilemma, decision makers do not always perceive the decision in the same way (e.g., Plous, 1993). Moreover, these differing perceptions may hold important implications for the validity of a social dilemma analysis of the decision in question.…”

Common Brain Regions with Distinct Patterns of Neural Responses during Mentalizing about Groups and Individuals

“…In this research, perceivers use stereotypes about the groups to which targets belong to infer the intentions and preferences of these targets (Bottom & Paese, 1997;Plous, 1993;Sagar & Schofield, 1980), especially when they view targets to be substantially different from them (Ames, Weber, & Zou, 2012;Ames, 2004aAmes, , 2004b. Further evidence of a link between mentalizing and stereotyping is provided by a neuroimaging experiment that suggests that these two operations recruit similar brain regions (Contreras, Banaji, & Mitchell, 2012).…”

The Role of EU Innovation Policies in the Sustainable Development of the Energy Sector

“…Systematic innovation is driven by system approaches to invention which is created and promoted mainly in universities and research centers. The R&D paradigm of innovation is closely linked to "cold war", when the two leading superpowers, the communist USSR and capitalist USA, got involved in so called "arms' race" (Plous, 1993). Despite the world was on the verge of extinction, the global society benefited from many inventions including the internet.…”