The mura’ah al-khilaf and ma’alat method in fatwa decisions: its application for fatwa coordination related to conditional hibah in Malaysia

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to study the differences in fatwa amongst official fatwa institutions in Malaysia comprising the State Mufti’s Departments (SMDs), the National Fatwa Committee Muzakarah (NFCM) and the National Bank Shariah Advisory Council (NBSAC) regarding the conditional gift issue and to propose a uniformed fatwa by taking an approach of celebrating views of all the official fatwa institutions involved. Design/methodology/approach The methodology used for this study is qualitative; data was collectedthrough library research and field studies.[AQ1] The library research was accomplished by examining books, statutes and related circulars, while field studies were conducted through unstructured interviews with eight Shariah (Sharia) officers and two academicians from SMDs, NFCM, NBSAC and public universities. Findings The findings of the study found that the conditional hibah (ruqba and 'umra) is valid as far as gifting is concerned, while the conditions pertaining to it are null and void. The findings also found that the concept of mura’ah al-khilaf and ma’alat al-af’al can be practised by applying conditional hibah to maintain maslahah, as provided under the concept of maqasid al-Shariah. Hence, this study proposed that formal fatwa institutions consisting of SMDs, NFCM and NBSAC issue a comprehensive guideline in contracting conditional hibah by providing an explicit provision on the recognised and different opinions about the said hibah. Originality/value The study analyses the differences of opinions of the official fatwa on conditional hibah issued by SMDs, NFCM and NBSAC based on the discipline of usul al-fiqh. It is found that conditional hibah is not allowed in Islamic law. It also found that conditional hibah granted by the NBSAC is not in adherence to the strict permission granted by Islamic law. Therefore, taking into consideration all the fatwas issued by the fatwa bodies, the researchers proposed to celebrate all official fatwas using the method of mura'ah al-khilaf and ma’alat al-af'al.

The Role of The Perlis State Mufti Department in Restraining Covid-19 Through Fatwas and Legal Guidelines

“…Thus, the mufti will conduct legal research to provide answers to the issues raised. Since the early generations of Islam, this concept has been going on (Asni & Sulong, 2021).…”

Joint-Ownership on Agricultural Land: A Case Study on Muamalah Contracts and The Shariah Model

“…Joint ownership is permissible, and it happens in Islam in a few muamalah contracts. Such ownership occurs either as a result of inheritance, partnership (syarikah), or bequeathed by someone in sharing mode or obtaining it through a gift (Asni & Sulong, 2021). It also appears among recipients of waqf benefit, especially under family waqf.…”

“…Apparently, all of the above transactions under the Islamic transactions have proven that joint ownership may happen, and some of it has already taken place through inheritance, partnership, will, gift, and waqf (Asni & Sulong, 2021). The discussions have shown that joint ownership is a common result that occurs from a contract.…”

The Role of Mura'ah al-Khilaf Epistemology in the Standardisation of Fatwa: An Analysis at the Perlis State Mufti Department

“…Based on the concept of ijtihad and fatwa, a person can perform ijtihad or fatwa if he has certain qualifications, such as understanding the pillars of inference (istinbat) in Shariah. This general concept allows various parties to issue ijtihad and fatwa (Asni & Sulong, 2021). Furthermore, there is a method of fiqh which states, "ijtihad cannot invalidate other ijtihad", causing multiple parties to issue their fatwas without the need to imitate or follow fatwas from other parties (al-Zuhaili, 2013).…”