The multilevel identity politics of the 2019 Eurovision Song Contest

Abstract

This article uses the 2019 Eurovision Song Contest (ESC) that took place in Tel Aviv to explore how cultural mega-events serve both as political arenas and as tools for identity construction, negotiation and contestation. These processes of identity politics are all conducted across national–subnational–international–transnational levels. The hosting of mega-events fleshes out these multiple processes in a very strong manner. We first discuss the politics of hosting mega-events in general. We then examine the identity politics associated more specifically with the Eurovision Song Contest, before examining in depth the complex forms of identity politics emerging around the competition following the 2018 Israeli victory. We suggest that it is important to study together the multiple processes—domestic, international and transnational—of identity politics that take place around the competition, as they interact with each other. Consequently, we follow the various stakeholders involved at these different levels and their interactions. We examine the internal identity negotiation process in Israel surrounding the event, the critical actors debating how to use the stage to challenge the liberal, western, ‘normal’ identity Israel hoped to project in the contest and how other stakeholders (participating states, national broadcasting agencies, participating artists) reacted to them, and finally we examine the behaviour of the institution in charge, the European Broadcasting Union, and national governments. We contribute to the study of mega-events as fields of contestation, to the understanding of the complex, multilevel nature of national identity construction, negotiation and contestation in the current era, and more broadly to the role that popular culture plays in this context.

The Refugee Paradox During Wartime in Europe: How Ukrainian and Afghan Refugees are (not) Alike

“…However, symbolic threat consists of more than (not) sharing value systems and worldviews (Stephan, Ybarra and Morrison 2009). Ukraine is strongly represented in mass events on a global scale that contribute to a conscience collective among audiences and participants of these events, such as mass sporting events or music festivals (Bravo et al 2020; Press-Barnathan and Lutz 2020). The representation of a country in such events is not trivial, nor are its effects.…”

External perceptions of the European Union in Israel—the role of norms and culture

“…Both the question of shared values and Israelis’ contradictory perceptions of Europe were well reflected when Israel hosted the ESC in 2019. As Israel was struggling to maintain the legitimacy of its political stance toward Palestinians in the face of the transnational Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement, Netta Barzilai's victory and Israel's subsequent hosting of the 2019 ESC were seen as an opportunity to improve Israel's image (Press-Barnathan and Luz, 2020; Rosler and Press-Barnathan, 2021). Israel was given an opportunity to be part of Europe.…”

The populist way out: Why contemporary populist leaders seek transnational legitimation

“…The research agenda on international legitimacy also benefits theoretically and empirically from analyses of populist leaders who are facing legitimation deficits, crises and struggles. As legitimation dynamics have been broadly addressed in international organisations (Dellmuth and Tallberg 2020; Dingwerth et al, 2020; Tallberg and Zürn, 2019), regional organisations (Lenz et al, 2019; Mace, 2020; Spandler, 2020; Wajner and Kacowicz, 2018), non-governmental organisations (Press-Barnathan and Lutz, 2020; Wajner, 2017), nation-states (see Gilley, 2009; Goddard and Krebs, 2015), and world powers (Lake, 2009; Reus-Smith 2007), the focus on this overlooked political actor is quite novel.…”