The Multi-Level Governance of Wales: Layer Cake or Marble Cake?

Abstract

Provides a reading of the literatures on multi-level governance and federalism to develop a series of propositions about the nature of the relationship between different levels of government in the devolved United Kingdom.• Drawing on a survey of local government officers in Wales, the article reports support for both layer cake and marble cake interpretations of multi-level governance. • The article concludes with a discussion of the applicability of these models to our understanding of devolution in the United Kingdom.Since the United Kingdom began its devolution programme in 1999 governments operating at four different territorial scales-embracing the EU, the UK, the national and the local-have played a part in the governance of Wales. Multi-level governance of this type can be likened to a layer cake, in which each government operates in its own distinct jurisdiction, or to a marble cake in which governments have overlapping and interlaced responsibilities. Drawing on a survey that asked senior officers in Welsh local government to rate the impact of different levels of government, this article finds support for both interpretations of multi-level governance. Although largely discredited as a description of American federalism, the layer cake simile may have a new lease of life in the analysis of Europe's devolved nations and regions.

Do public consultations work? The case of the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Bill

“…It may also demonstrate that Welsh policy making and influencing Welsh policy is seen as an important part of policy work by organisations outside Wales. This aspect links with the wider debate about multi-level governance in Wales (Entwistle et al, 2014) as well as the question as to who populates the policy space, and to what extent, in devolved nations. The analysis of submissions to public consultations may provide some useful empirical material for a subsequent mapping of the policy arena.…”

Political trust in France’s multi-level government

“…The choice of the French case captures contextually specific dynamics (the dispersion of policy-making dynamics in a formal unitary state), but also provides more general testable propositions in relation to other country cases, namely: the role of political trust in function-specific and general purpose forms of local and (Hooghe and Marks, 2001, p. 1). Borrowing a metaphor from the federalism literature, the French model of MLG is more akin to a marble cake (random and fruity), rather than a well-ordered layer cake, with neatly distributed competencies between levels (Entwistle et al, 2014). Unlike in many systems of territorial administration, there is no formal hierarchy between levels of local and regional authority.…”

Multi-level Governance: Conceptual challenges and case studies from Australia

“…This has been noticeable in federal jurisdictions within the EU, such as Germany, as well as countries that have undergone devolution, such as the United Kingdom (e.g. Börzel and Hölsi 2003;Asare et al 2009;Schmidt 1999;Benz and Zimmer 2010;Entwistle et al 2012;Piattoni 2012 the sort of multi-centred collaboration that is now being contemplated, and that could involve federal, provincial, municipal, Aboriginal, and foreign governments, as well as transnational institutions, will be much more complex and increasingly political than earlier federal-provincial interactions.…”