The Multi-Annual Residency of Juvenile Smooth Hammerhead Shark in an Oceanic Island Nursery

Abstract

The increased risk of local extinction becomes critical for sharks depending on the narrow and isolated coastal habitats of oceanic islands. This includes large pelagic oceanic sharks that use such habitats as nurseries, as previously hypothesized for the smooth hammerhead Sphyrna zygaena, the least known of cosmopolitan large hammerhead sharks. We used a combination of acoustic and satellite telemetry in a juvenile population of Faial and Pico islands, Azores, mid-north Atlantic, to confirm if this isolated archipelago holds nurseries, and to answer questions related to their function and spatial–temporal stability. Our long-term acoustic tracking data showed a cluster of individual core home ranges in specific areas of north shore Faial, and surface positions from five Argos-linked tagged individuals also showed a clustering overlap in those areas for up to 1 year. These patterns seem to reveal a true habitat preference within the Faial-Pico island (sub) population of juvenile smooth hammerhead shark, and thus constitute strong evidence for this area to be considered a nursery. Some individuals remained in this nursery for up to 4 years, especially during summers. Sharks also showed a strong diel behavior, typically using the inshore nurseries during the day and moving further offshore during the night, during which they increased activity and dove deeper, most possibly to feed. We speculate that a combination of increased feeding opportunities, expanded trophic niche, and reduced predatory pressure may be a key evolutionary driver for the existence, prolonged use, and even preference of coastal nurseries at oceanic islands by juvenile smooth hammerhead shark. Given that these nurseries may constitute essential fish habitat for this species, they should be explicitly included in spatial management measures at the local and regional scales, as they may also play a role of greater importance to the north Atlantic population of this oceanic species.

Regional population and seascape genomics of the smooth hammerhead shark Sphyrna zygaena reveals adaptive clinal variation despite high gene flow

“…Interestingly, reports from a previous capture-mark-recapture study conducted off the eastern coast of South Africa reported limited average travel distances for S. zygaena (Diemer et al, 2011). This is contrary to the high coastal connectivity implied by the current and recent study (Félix-López et al, 2024) in addition to satellite-tagging projects conducted in the Atlantic (Santos and Coelho, 2018;Logan et al 2020); however, it could be explained by the fact that recaptured individuals were mainly juveniles (precaudal length < 150 cm), which are known to mostly remain in coastal nursery habitats (Smale, 1991;Afonso et al 2022;Albano et al 2023). Moreover, significant differences in fishing effort and recapture reporting could significantly bias estimates (Diemer et al, 2011).…”