The Movement to Decriminalize Sex Work in Gauteng Province, South Africa, 1994-2002

Abstract

This article explores the movement to decriminalize sex work in the Gauteng province of Johannesburg from 1994 to 2002. In particular, I examine the actions and statements of the provincial Ministry of Safety and Security and other ministries in the decision to de facto decriminalize prostitution using the international language of human rights. This article illustrates that the movement to decriminalize sex work in the postapartheid period is not a sharp departure from the past. Rather, as early as the 1970s there were minority contingents that advocated a legalization or decriminalization of sex work, arguing for the public health or policy benefits that would follow. What is new in the postapartheid period is the justification for decriminalization, which now is based on the international language of human rights. Also new in the postapartheid period is the inclusion in the debate of voices that were not heard during apartheid, when die media was dominated by white South Africans. There is now a counterdiscourse opposing decriminalization, based on religion and on the argument that sex work is "un-African."

Sex work and the 2010 FIFA World Cup: time for public health imperatives to prevail

“…And for almost a decade, the country has been reviewing its sexual offences legislation and considering reform of sex work laws [52,53]. It would have been prudent for these processes to have been concluded before the 2010 World Cup, but the South African Law Reform Commission will reportedly only release its recommendations on law reform and sex work in 2011 [54].…”

Constituting the Unsafe: Nigerian Sex Workers' Notions of Unsafe Sexual Conduct

“…Since the 1980s, when HIV emerged as a ranking social issue in Africa, sex workers in the continent have remained on the research and policy agenda. Frequently accused of complicity in the spread and sustenance of the epidemic, sex workers have entered and remained in the wider African social imaginary as folk devils (Wojcicki 2003;Altman 2001;Hunter 2002). As a result, research and policy focusing on sex workers have concentrated on finding ways to minimize their involvement in unsafe sexual practices.…”

Sex Laws and Sexuality Rights in Comparative and Global Perspectives

“…Through the lens of human rights, ageof-consent laws-intended to protect children from sexual exploitation-may be reinterpreted as violations of youth rights to sexual freedom (Graupner 2005). Through the lens of human rights, prostitution laws may be reconceived as interfering with women's (and men's) right to work (Bernstein 2007, McCarthy et al 2012, Outshoorn 2004, Wojcicki 2003. Each intersection between new human rights and old national laws produces opportunities for scholarly analysis.…”

“…In fact, the human rights framework is used to justify the decriminalization of sex work (Wojcicki 2003). Research from this perspective focuses on how the workers view and interpret their own participation in the sex trade (Agustín 2005, Piscitelli 2007.…”