The Moral Magic of Consent

Abstract

We regularly wield powers that, upon close scrutiny, appear remarkably magical. By sheer exercise of will, we bring into existence things that have never existed before. With but a nod, we effect the disappearance of things that have long served as barriers to the actions of others. And, by mere resolve, we generate things that pose significant obstacles to others' exercise of liberty. What is the nature of these things that we create and destroy by our mere decision to do so? The answer: the rights and obligations of others. And by what seemingly magical means do we alter these rights and obligations? By making promises and issuing or revoking consent When we make promises, we generate obligations for ourselves, and when we give consent, we create rights for others. Since the rights and obligations that are affected by means of promising and consenting largely define the boundaries of permissible action, our exercise of these seemingly magical powers can significantly affect the lives and liberties of others.

Despairing about War: The Democratic Limits of Pessimism

“…Such choices reflect what people might settle for, as opposed to normatively aspire and positively affirm. I would argue that only when these commitments and choices deeply converge can choice have what Heidi Hurd (1996) call the "moral magic" of consent.…”

The Moral Rules of Trash Talking: Morality and Ownership

“…See Hurd (1996). Larry Alexander provides a sufficient condition that reduces consent to a forgoing of objection to, roughly, what the second does.…”

Consent and the Problem of Framing Effects

“…As we shall soon see, it is the view that seems to face the most significant challenge from the prevalence of framing effects. 4 This is what Heidi Hurd (1996) refers to as consent's "moral magic." See also Manson and O'Neill (2007, pp.…”