A link between Pro catabolism and mitochondrial reactive oxygen species production has been established across eukaryotes and in plants increases in leaf respiration rates have been reported following Pro exposure. Here we investigated how alternative oxidases (AOXs) of the mitochondrial electron transport chain accommodate the large, atypical flux resulting from Pro catabolism and limit oxidative stress during Pro breakdown in mature Arabidopsis leaves. Following Pro treatment, AOX1a and AOX1d accumulate at transcript and protein levels, with AOX1d approaching the level of the typically dominant AOX1a isoform. We therefore sought to determine the function of both AOX isoforms under Pro respiring conditions. Oxygen consumption rate measurements in aox1a and aox1d leaves suggested these AOXs can functionally compensate for each other to establish enhanced AOX catalytic capacity in response to Pro. Generation of aox1a.aox1d lines showed complete loss of AOX proteins and activity upon Pro treatment, yet respiratory induction in response to Pro was still possible via the cytochrome pathway. However, aox1a.aox1d leaves suffered increased levels of oxidative stress and damage during Pro metabolism compared to WT or the single mutants. During recovery from salt stress, when high rates of Pro catabolism occur naturally, photosynthetic rates in aox1a.aox1d recovered slower than WT or the single aox lines, showing that both AOX1a and AOX1d are beneficial for cellular metabolism during Pro drawdown following osmotic stress. This work provides physiological evidence of a beneficial role for AOX1a but also the less studied AOX1d isoform in allowing safe catabolism of alternative respiratory substrates like Pro.