In the North Pacific, a maximum in baroclinic instability during mid winter does not yield higher baroclinic activity, a conundrum termed the “mid-winter suppression” of eddy activity. The degree of instability is typically measured by the Eady growth rate. A recently proposed classification into subtropical and eddy-driven jets sheds new light on this conundrum. While the strength of the subtropical jets increases during midwinter, the strength of the eddy-driven jet decreases. Consequently, the Eady growth rate for eddy-driven jets decreases in tandem with the reduced eddy activity during mid-winter, only the environment for subtropical jets becomes more unstable. The increase in baroclinic instability for subtropical jets does, however, not translate into increased eddy activity, as baroclinic growth rates for the subtropical jet remain below growth rates for the eddy-driven jet throughout winter. Thus, the conundrum of the mid-winter suppression can be resolved by considering the environments around subtropical and eddy-driven jet types in isolation.