The medicalisation of shyness: from social misfits to social fitness

Abstract

Shyness has become an 'unhealthy' state of mind for individuals living in contemporary Western societies. Insofar as its behavioural 'symptoms' imply a failure to achieve certain cultural values, such as assertiveness, self-expression and loquacious vocality, shyness is increasingly defined as a problem for which people can, and should, be treated. This paper first critically discusses the idea that we are witnessing a new 'cultural epidemic' of shyness, as evidenced by increasing rates of diagnosis for Social Phobia, Social Anxiety Disorder and Avoidant Personality Disorder. It then examines three main dimensions of the medicalisation of shyness: biomedical and genetic approaches, the therapeutic interventions of cognitive-behaviour therapy and 'shyness clinics', and the disciplinary regimes imposed by self-help books and websites. Within a cultural climate of pervasive anxiety and privatised risk, the medicalisation of shyness suggests a powerful new way of defining and managing certain kinds of deviant identities, but we can also find some evidence of resistance to this approach.

Changes in the Diagnosis of Autism: How Parents and Professionals Act and React in France

“…A questionnaire and a letter were sent to parents. In total, 248 questionnaires completed by parents were obtained from all over France between 2005 and2006. Of the 248 questionnaires, 71% were completed by the mothers, 29% by the fathers, and 48 couples completed two questionnaires.…”

The performative turn in the assessment of student learning: a rights perspective

“…To some extent this finding acts as a salutary reminder of the classic literature in this area which indicates that more introverted students are capable of doing well by using their own individual study methods whereas more extroverted students perform better in seminars where oral participation is used (Entwistle and Entwistle 1970;Furnham 1992;Furnham and Medhurst 1995). The use of forms of assessment which emphasize vocal loquacity, such as class contribution or oral presentations, provides more challenges for the shy or quiet individual now increasingly defined as a deviant in the university learning environment and society at large (Scott 2006;Reda 2009). …”

What is the DSM? Diagnostic manual, cultural icon, political battleground: an overview with suggestions for a critical research agenda

“…See Porter (2013) for a discussion of the construct of validity espoused in DSM-III and its origins in the work of Robins & Guze (1970). iv This critique has been formulated in relation to specific sentiments or conditions such as shyness/social phobia (Lane, 2008;Scott, 2006), sadness/depressive disorder (Horwitz &Wakefield, 2007) and female sexual dysfunction (e.g. Moynihan, 2003;Tiefer, 2006); but also in more general terms in relation to the concept of the 'normal', most notably by the Chair of the Task Force for DSM-IV Allan Frances (Frances, 2013).…”