Let n ≥ 3 be an integer. In this paper, we prove several theorems concerning the average behavior of the 2-torsion in class groups of rings defined by integral binary n-ic forms having any fixed odd leading coefficient and ordered by height. Specifically, we compute an upper bound on the average size of the 2-torsion in the class groups of maximal orders arising from such binary forms; as a consequence, we deduce that most such orders have odd class number. When n is even, we compute corresponding upper bounds on the average size of the 2-torsion in the oriented and narrow class groups of maximal orders; moreover, we obtain an upper bound on the average number of non-trivial 2-torsion elements in the ordinary, oriented, and narrow class groups of notnecessarily-maximal orders, where we declare a 2-torsion class to be trivial if it is represented by a 2-torsion ideal. We further prove that each of these upper bounds is in fact an equality, conditional on a conjectural uniformity estimate that is known to hold when n = 3.To prove these theorems, we first answer a question of Ellenberg by parametrizing square roots of the class of the different of a ring arising from a binary form in terms of the integral orbits of a certain representation. Since the set of square roots of the class of the different is a torsor for the 2-torsion in the class group, this new parametrization allows us to count 2-torsion classes.Our theorems extend recent work of Bhargava-Hanke-Shankar in the cubic case and of Siad in the monic n-ic case to binary forms of any degree having any fixed odd leading coefficient. When n is odd, our result demonstrates that fixing the leading coefficient has the surprising effect of augmenting the average 2-torsion in the class group, relative to the prediction given by the heuristics of Cohen-Lenstra-Martinet-Malle. When n is even, analogous heuristics are yet to be formulated; together with Siad's results in the monic case, our theorems are the first of their kind to describe the average behavior of the p-torsion in class groups of n-ic rings where p | n > 2.