The managerial turn and municipal land-use planning in Switzerland – evidence from practice

Abstract

New Public Management (NPM) reforms are intended to increase efficiency and support a more managerial approach to public problems. This paper examines how NPM-type reforms have led to the growing influence of finance and realestate departments in local level planning in Switzerland. Drawing on over 50 interviews, the paper maps the growing influence of flexible private-law or incentive-based instruments as complements to more binding instruments (typically zoning) in land-use planning practices. NPM reforms have prompted a renewed interest in public property, forcing municipalities to position themselves in relation to the necessity to sell or retain public land. The results show that NPM has affected practices of landuse planning in Switzerland, but the outcomes are more complex than a one-to-one takeover and there is variation across the country. The Swiss case study helps extend the wider international debate about NPM and planning. This paper highlights the complex impacts of managerialism on planning reform as well as ongoing tensions between increased efficiency in plan implementation and public scrutiny.

Land-policy instruments for densification: the Dutch quest for control

“…Examples of instruments for this type of approach are compulsory purchase and land banking. Governments in, for example, The Netherlands, Finland, Sweden, China, and Singapore actively intervene in land markets (Lichtenberg & Ding, 2009;Ooi et al, 2011;Needham, 2014;Valtonen et al, 2016), and in countries such as Switzerland, Luxembourg, United Kingdom, France, and Spain a more active role on the land market is under serious consideration (Munoz-Gielen, 2011;Becker & Hesse, 2011;Knoepfel et al, 2012;Monk et al, 2013;Gerber, 2016). Even where a local government applies an active approach, urban densification can be challenging, because of scarcely available land.…”

The strategic use of time-limited property rights in land-use planning: Evidence from Switzerland

“…Land-use planning is the ''process by which public agencies, mostly local governments, determine the intensity and geographical arrangements of various land uses in a community'' (Fulton, 1999: 7). Land-use planning is a public policy (Gerber, 2016). As such, it aims to solve a public problem (e.g.…”

Planning for compact urban forms: local growth-management approaches and their evolution over time

“…The present study clearly shows that land-management and quality-oriented measures have already been introduced in large and very large municipalities for some decades. Gerber (2016) argues that such growth-management approaches-implemented through economic intervention and management-have been encouraged since the mid-1990s by the introduction of New Public Management reforms in municipal administrations. However, this managerial turn mainly occurred in municipalities of more than 10,000 inhabitants, while small municipalities did not apply these principles extensively (Steiner and Ladner 2006).…”