The Magnitude of Tissue Cooling During Cryotherapy With Varied Types of Compression

Abstract

Context: Certified athletic trainers can choose different types of external compression (none, Flex-i-Wrap, and elastic wrap) when applying an ice bag to the body. However, which type facilitates the greatest magnitude of tissue cooling is unclear.Objective: To compare the effects of 2 common types of external compression on the magnitude of surface and intramuscular cooling during an ice-bag treatment.Design: Randomized controlled trial. Setting: University research laboratory.Patients or Other Participants: Fourteen college students (10 women, 4 men; age 5 22.4 6 1.8 years, height 5 169.1 6 8.2 cm, mass 5 73.3 6 18.5 kg, skinfold 5 13.14 6 1.61 mm) with previous cryotherapy experience and a posterior lower leg skinfold equal to or less than 15 mm.Intervention(s): On 3 different days separated by 24 to 48 hours, an ice bag was applied to the posterior lower leg surface of each participant for 30 minutes with no compression, with elastic wrap, or with Flex-i-Wrap.Main Outcome Measure(s): Posterior lower leg surface and intramuscular (2 cm) temperatures were recorded for 95 minutes.Results: At 15 minutes, the elastic wrap produced greater surface temperature reduction than no compression (P 5 .03); this difference remained throughout the protocol (P range, .03 to .04). At 30 minutes, surface temperatures were 14.956C, 11.556C, and 9.496C when an ice bag was applied with no external compression, Flex-i-Wrap, and elastic wrap, respectively. Surface temperatures between Flex-i-Wrap and elastic wrap and between Flex-i-Wrap and no compression were never different. At 10 minutes, Flex-i-Wrap (P 5 .006) and elastic wrap (P , .001) produced greater intramuscular temperature reduction than no compression produced; these differences remained throughout the protocol. At 10 minutes, no compression, Flex-iWrap, and elastic wrap decreased intramuscular temperature by 1.346C, 2.466C, and 2.736C, respectively. At 25 minutes, elastic wrap (8.036C) produced greater temperature reduction than Flexi-Wrap (6.656C) (P 5 .03) or no compression (4.636C) (P , .001 ). These differences remained throughout ice application and until 50 minutes after ice-bag removal.Conclusions: During an ice-bag application, external compression with elastic wrap was more effective than Flex-i-Wrap at reducing intramuscular tissue temperature. Elastic wraps should be used for acute injury care.Key Words: intramuscular temperatures, surface temperatures, insulation Key Points N External compression of an ice bag with an elastic wrap provided greater temperature reduction after a 30-minute treatment than did compression with Flex-i-Wrap. N Intramuscular temperature decreases were different but surface temperature decreases were not different between Flex-iWrap and elastic wrap compression.N Intramuscular temperature was lower with compression than with no compression at 10 minutes and was lower with elastic wrap than with Flex-i-Wrap at 25 minutes.N Compression with elastic wrap demonstrated a higher average atmosphere-interface temperature than the other con...

Reliability and Validity of Near-Infrared Spectroscopy Mitochondrial Capacity Measurement in Skeletal Muscle

“…The order of the visits was counterbalanced. The skin surface was cooled to 15.6 • C using four commercially available cold packs for 20 min on the forearm and calf, and 25 min on the thigh [13]. The forearm and calf skin surface was heated to 40 • C using a commercially available electric heat pack for 20 min, while the thigh was heated for 25 min.…”

Cold Suppresses Agonist-induced Activation of TRPV1

“…In TRPV1-HEK cells, CAP-induced current (I CAP ) was robustly attenuated by decreasing bath temperature to 16°C and 10°C, which is within the range of skin surface temperature achieved by the application of an ice pack (Tomchuk et al, 2010). Approximately 70% inhibition was achieved at 10°C (Fig.…”

Variação de temperatura do músculo quadríceps femoral exposto a duas modalidades de crioterapia por meio de termografia

“…Tomchuk et al 11 also observed that the intramuscular temperature remained decreasing from 2ºC to 3ºC after 10 minutes after ice removal, before gradually increasing to basal levels.…”