The link between multilingualism, language learning and open-mindedness in secondary school students in Norway

Abstract

A positive link between open-mindedness and multilingualism suggested in intercultural psychology research (e.g., Dewaele & Botes, 2020; Korzilius et al., 2011; Dewaele & Oudenhoven, 2009) has also been implicitly assumed in Norway’s Core Curriculum (NDET, 2017) and in the curricula for English (NDET, 2019a) and Foreign Languages (NDET, 2019b). However, little empirical research has been conducted to explore how becoming multilingual, especially through learning foreign languages at school, can be connected to the development of students’ open-mindedness. The present study addresses this gap by exploring open-mindedness in lower secondary school students (n=593) learning one or two foreign languages in school. In addition, other factors related to students’ multilingualism, such as their multilingual identity, migration background, experience living abroad and having friends with home languages other than Norwegian, are also considered to better understand the complex relationship between open-mindedness and multilingualism in the school context. By analysing the data collected with the Ungspråk questionnaire (Haukås et al., 2021a), the study reveals no particular relationship between open-mindedness and students’ migration background and experience of living abroad. However, it indicates that open-mindedness is positively linked to L3 learning at school, multilingual identity and having friends who use other languages at home. These findings have significant pedagogical implications suggesting that promoting learning a second foreign language at lower secondary school, developing students’ self-identification as multilingual and encouraging the interaction with peers speaking further languages may contribute to the enhancement of open-mindedness among students.
 Keywords: open-mindedness, multilingualism, multilingual identity, foreign language learning, L2, L3

Pockets of Possibility: Students of English in Diverse, Multilingual Secondary Schools in Austria

“…It thus appears particularly valuable that teachers create a positive classroom atmosphere in the vocational track schools, where students may be less confident about their language abilities as a result of being tracked into lower prestige schools. This finding lends strength to recent research suggesting the importance of developing positive multilingual identities amongst language learners at lower secondary schools (Fisher et al 2020;Tiurikova et al 2021).…”

Exploring the Systematic Use of Intercultural Encounters in the English Classroom

“…The subject of English is presented as an important building block in pupils' dynamic and developing linguistic and (inter)cultural repertoire. More specifically, in English, multilingualism may be promoted by an active, metacognitive approach in the classroom, and through a validation and awareness of all students' multilingual identities (Fisher et al, 2018;Tiurikova et al, 2021). Different multilingual and intercultural repertoires should be valued equally; dialects and regional variants should also be included here.…”

Change and Development in the Cultural Dimension of Language Teaching, and Beyond

“…Other scholars distinguish between linguistic identity and multilingual identity; they define these two as "associated but different; linguistic identity refers to the way one identifies (or is identified by others) in each of the languages in one's linguistic repertoire, whereas a multilingual identity is an 'umbrella' identity, where one explicitly identifies as multilingual precisely because of an awareness of the linguistic repertoire one has" (Fisher et al, 2018, p. 2). Tiurikova et al (2021) also discuss language and identity when they relate open-mindedness to L3-learning at school and multilingual identity (p. 1).…”