Abstract:The most archaeologically visible dimension of the Classic Maya Collapse is the abandonment of monumental royal courts. Yet, in some cases, non-elite populations lived for centuries in and around Classic Maya centers without rulers. Processes of abandonment among Classic Maya commoners are detectable and reflect their own ritual and social practices divorced from the ritual performances undertaken by the ruling elite. We study the abandonment context and chronology of three domestic groups from the Contreras V… Show more
“…The reasons for termination, whether reverential or desecratory, may affect the conditions of the objects. Desecratory termination may incorporate the destruction of locations by burning or damaging architectural features and/or burials, possibly associated with defeat in warfare (Demarest et al 1997;Garber 1983;Golden et al 2016;Harrison-Buck 2012, 2016Harrison-Buck et al 2007; Iannone 2005Iannone , 2010Inomata 2003Inomata , 2016Lamoureux-St-Hilaire et al 2015;Mock 1998b;Pagliaro et al 2003;Palka 2003;Schwake and Iannone 2016;Suhler and Freidel 2003;Yaeger 2010). Whether the product of desecratory or reverential termination, the conditions of the objects in problematic deposits can vary, with some being damaged or broken, conceivably on purpose, to "kill" them or remove their life-force (see Walker [1995] for "kratophanous material culture").…”
Problematic deposits, containing different types of artifacts and skeletal remains, are typically recovered on or near the surfaces of the terminal phase of elite civic-ceremonial architecture at ancient Maya sites. These contexts often date to the Terminal Classic period (~a.d. 750–900). They have been variously interpreted as evidence for site abandonment, squatting, warfare, or dedication or termination rituals. Sixteen chert bifaces were recovered from problematic deposits at the bases of Structures A2 and A3 in the elite Plaza A at Cahal Pech, Belize. Stone tools from problematic deposits are rarely examined in significant detail. Based on stylistic, metric, and use-wear analyses, the bifaces were likely produced locally, used during important hunting or warfare activities, and then ritually deposited in the Terminal Classic. These bifaces were likely hafted to spearthrower darts and represented “success” at hunting or fighting. The recovery of weaponry in problematic deposits that is not the direct result of warfare is an important observation because Mayanists have generally interpreted their presence in these contexts as evidence of warfare. The fact that the points were recovered in groups of seven and nine may indicate that they had important symbolic meanings that connected them to supernatural or mythological places or entities.
“…The reasons for termination, whether reverential or desecratory, may affect the conditions of the objects. Desecratory termination may incorporate the destruction of locations by burning or damaging architectural features and/or burials, possibly associated with defeat in warfare (Demarest et al 1997;Garber 1983;Golden et al 2016;Harrison-Buck 2012, 2016Harrison-Buck et al 2007; Iannone 2005Iannone , 2010Inomata 2003Inomata , 2016Lamoureux-St-Hilaire et al 2015;Mock 1998b;Pagliaro et al 2003;Palka 2003;Schwake and Iannone 2016;Suhler and Freidel 2003;Yaeger 2010). Whether the product of desecratory or reverential termination, the conditions of the objects in problematic deposits can vary, with some being damaged or broken, conceivably on purpose, to "kill" them or remove their life-force (see Walker [1995] for "kratophanous material culture").…”
Problematic deposits, containing different types of artifacts and skeletal remains, are typically recovered on or near the surfaces of the terminal phase of elite civic-ceremonial architecture at ancient Maya sites. These contexts often date to the Terminal Classic period (~a.d. 750–900). They have been variously interpreted as evidence for site abandonment, squatting, warfare, or dedication or termination rituals. Sixteen chert bifaces were recovered from problematic deposits at the bases of Structures A2 and A3 in the elite Plaza A at Cahal Pech, Belize. Stone tools from problematic deposits are rarely examined in significant detail. Based on stylistic, metric, and use-wear analyses, the bifaces were likely produced locally, used during important hunting or warfare activities, and then ritually deposited in the Terminal Classic. These bifaces were likely hafted to spearthrower darts and represented “success” at hunting or fighting. The recovery of weaponry in problematic deposits that is not the direct result of warfare is an important observation because Mayanists have generally interpreted their presence in these contexts as evidence of warfare. The fact that the points were recovered in groups of seven and nine may indicate that they had important symbolic meanings that connected them to supernatural or mythological places or entities.
“…In fact, many abandoned Preclassic and Classic period centres became pilgrimage destinations (Andres & Pyburn 2004;Brown 2011;Hansen et al 2008;Robin et al 2012). Where populations dwelled amongst the monumental ruins, they continued to interact with the past on a daily basis (Halperin 2014;Lamoureux-St-Hilaire et al 2015;Mixter 2017a;Navarro-Farr 2016). Perhaps because of their association with transcendent cosmological concepts, triadic pyramid groups in particular remained places of reverence (Halperin 2014).…”
To remain in place in the immediate aftermath of the ninth-century Maya collapse, Maya groups employed various resilient strategies. In the absence of divine rulers, groups needed to renegotiate their forms of political authority and to reconsider the legitimizing role of religious institutions. This kind of negotiation happened first at the local level, where individual communities developed varied political and ideological solutions. At the community of Actuncan, located in the lower Mopan River valley of Belize, reorganization took place within the remains of a monumental urban centre built 1000 years before by the site's early rulers. I report on the changing configuration and use of Actuncan's urban landscape during the process of reorganization. These modifications included the construction of a new centre for political gatherings, the dismantling of old administrative buildings constructed by holy lords and the reuse of the site's oldest ritual space. These developments split the city into distinct civic and ritual zones, paralleling the adoption of a new shared rule divorced from cosmological underpinnings. This case study provides an example of how broader societal resilience relies on adaptation at the local level.
“…Considerable doubt has justifiably been raised about the ceremonial significance of exposed offerings . We argue that, to be most convincing, termination rituals should be associated with structural primary deposits, tying all offerings within a localized ritual cycle (Lamoureux-St-Hilaire et al 2015).…”
Section: Gradual and Organized Abandonment-ritualmentioning
We present a behavioral-contextual method for studying abandonment-related assemblages in order to ascribe them to a settlement abandonment scenario. Our approach examines the vertical and horizontal architectural contexts of assemblages, along with the nature of reconstructible vessels and other artifacts. This method accounts for gradual, rapid, mundane, and ceremonial abandonment scenarios, and for abandonment with anticipated return. Two advantages of this model are its replicability and its proposition of a shared taxonomy leading away from the concept of problematic deposits. The method is contextualized with two distinct case studies from the southern Maya lowlands: the palace of La Corona, Guatemala and an agricultural household group from greater Minanha, Belize. These dissimilar but contemporary (ca. A.D. 900) contexts revealed complex abandonment-related assemblages, including pre-abandonment middens, de facto and secondary material, and on-floor, exposed offerings. Both case studies are argued to reflect gradual, organized abandonment scenarios, although with significant temporal and behavioral distinctions.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.