The radical S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM) enzyme HydG cleaves tyrosine to generate CO and CN − ligands of the [FeFe] hydrogenase H-cluster, accompanied by the formation of a 4-oxidobenzyl radical (4-OB • ), which is the precursor to the HydG p-cresol byproduct. Native HydG only generates a small amount of 4-OB • , limiting detailed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectral characterization beyond our initial EPR lineshape study employing various tyrosine isotopologues. Here, we show that the concentration of trapped 4-OB • is significantly increased in reactions using HydG variants, in which the "dangler Fe" to which CO and CN − bind is missing or substituted by a redox-inert Zn 2+ ion. This allows for the detailed characterization of 4-OB • using high-field EPR and electron nuclear double resonance spectroscopy to extract its g-values and 1 H/ 13 C hyperfine couplings. These results are compared to density functional theory-predicted values of several 4-OB • models with different sizes and protonation states, with a best fit to the deprotonated radical anion configuration of 4-OB • . Overall, our results depict a clearer electronic structure of the transient 4-OB • radical and provide new insights into the radical SAM chemistry of HydG.