The Intersections of Good Intentions, Criminality, and Anti-Carceral Feminist Logic: A Qualitative Study that Explores Sex Trades Content in Social Work Education

Abstract

This study uses anti-carceral feminist logic to explore the cultural meanings, criminal implications, and neoliberal influence that shape the landscape of social work education about the sex trades in the United States and transnationally. "What are social work instructors teaching students about the sex trades in coursework?" is the question that directs the study, which uses a feminist qualitative methodology inclusive of intersectional feminist epistemology as well as direct content analysis. To answer this question, I analyzed 20 social work course syllabi from sex trade related courses across the contiguous United States and interviewed 20 social work instructors from 14 different states.Study findings show that course content represents people in the sex trades primarily as victimized cisgender women and girls with a significant focus on sex trafficking, especially within the Global South. While there is some course content that portrays sex trade workers as having complex and autonomous experiences, this material is limited to courses that have "sex" or "sexuality" in the title (i.e. "sex trafficking" or "sexuality and social work" courses). Furthermore, course content that represents the intersectional experiences and impact of systemic violence encountered by trans women of color and LGBTQ+ people is underrepresented in the sample--confined to two course syllabi and visibly absent from remaining syllabi. The sample indicates the prevalence of carceral approaches to the sex trades with an unexamined and racially-biased emphasis upon rescue and/or incarceration. This project provides significant implications for social work education about the necessity of an anti-carceral feminist, intersectional, and consequently, an anti-oppressive approach to teaching about the sex trades.ii Dedication Adrienne, my teenage witch sister and sex work training partner, how do I even count the ways. Your critical insight on community building, accountability, systems of power, feminism, social work, and sex trade has been such a major contribution to my thinking, research, teaching, writing, dreaming, and loving during my time in PhD land. Thank you for being you, for seeing me, and for learning and growing with me.

Sex Worker Collectives Within the Whorearchy: Intersectional Inquiry with Sex Workers in Los Angeles, CA

“…If social workers are currently only able to programmatically assist sex workers who have the capacity to comply with the demands of the state, we must dismantle police collaborations and shift to an anti-carceral social work model to provide life-affirming services to sex workers (Jacobs et al, 2021). However, the current knowledge we receive about sex workers primes us to assume that all sex workers need to be rescued with the help of carceral interventions (Panichelli, 2018). This study contributes to other studies that worked collaboratively with sex workers to co-produce knowledge that is affirming of their experiences to inform policy and practice (Desyllas, 2013; Grittner & Sitter, 2020; Wahab, 2004).…”

An Epidemic of Virtue: A Review of Social Work's Complicity in “Prostitution” Interventions

“…The Violence Against Women Act and Mass Incarceration. In 1994, the federal government passed the Violence Against Women Act, injecting 800 million dollars into law enforcement agencies to increase arrest policies, prosecute domestic violence, and create services for survivors of domestic violence (Panichelli, 2018). It also sent 100,000 more police into the streets and earmarked 10 billion dollars for prisons (Mac & Smith, 2018).…”

Defund the Police: Moving Towards an Anti-Carceral Social Work

“…They have resulted in a myriad of programs that leverage arrest, compliance with law enforcement, and subjugation to moral rescue from the sex trade to aid "victims of crime," even when voluntarily chosen as forms of work (Bernstein, 2010;Panichelli, 2018). Indeed, the TOWARDS ANTI-CARCERAL SOCIAL WORK 11 landmark legislation applauded for its recognition of gender-based violence as a crime, the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) of 1994, was passed as a part of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act, federal legislation featuring a set of draconian policies that further accelerated hyperincarceration and concretized collaboration between the anti-violence field and the carceral state (Kim, 2013).…”