Purpose of this paper: This paper provides a paradigm for the creation of a civilian review board. To illustrate this model, themes of a civilian board's connection to the community, establishment of the board, and criminal psychological implications for the future of the selection and retention of police officers are discussed. High profile police incidents (e.g., Freddy Gray, Charleston, SC and Chicago Police Shooting Laquan McDonald, etc.) have forced departments to grapple with a question that has long been latent in the experiences of ethnoracially diverse citizens. What is generally known about frequency and types of crimes committed by police? Answering this question, may function as justification for or against greater external citizen review of suspected crimes committed by police.