The Institutionalisation of a Creative Practice: Changing Roles of Regional Design in Dutch National Planning

Balz, Verena; Zonneveld, Wil

doi:10.1007/978-3-030-23573-4_3

Cited by 4 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 27 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Meskipun demikian, terdapat beberapa poin yang membuat sifat keumuman lomba ini mengalami reduksi, yakni adanya prasyarat sertifikat keahlian tertentu 6 untuk bisa diterima sebagai pendaftar. Proses ini adalah ejawantah dari kehati-hatian dalam mempertimbangkan publik yang bisa terlibat dalam perencanaan wilayah (Balz & Zonneveld, 2020).…”

Section: Pendahuluanunclassified

Proyek Lintas Batas Administrasi: Analisis Partisipasi Publik dalam Proses Perencanaan Ibu Kota Negara Republik Indonesia

Hamdani

2020

JP2WD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Administrative Transboundary Project: Public Participation Analysis in Indonesia’s New Capital City Planning Processes The Central Government of the Republic of Indonesia once again formulated a plan for moving the National Capital (IKN). The existing government centers in DKI Jakarta Province will be moved to North Penajam Paser Regency and Kutai Kartanegara Regency in East Kalimantan Province. As the progress of planning and preparation for the implementation of this discourse, public opinion is still dominated by negative sentiment, one of the escalated issues is public participation. As the core of democracy, public participation in decision making in the Republic of Indonesia is a necessity. This study intends to review the IKN planning process that has been carried out from the perspective of the participation ladder theory. Descriptive qualitative method used by analyzing electronic news (understanding chronological stories of the project) and media social data (public participation and perception). Comparing those data with previous researches were done to increase depth of analysis. The result showed that participatory regional planning process in IKN project is in the degree of tokenism or symbolism. This is hoped to provide evaluation in the implementation of the capital city relocation project, thus could contribute in creating more inclusive planning processes in further implementation stages.

show abstract

Section: Pendahuluanunclassified

Proyek Lintas Batas Administrasi: Analisis Partisipasi Publik dalam Proses Perencanaan Ibu Kota Negara Republik Indonesia

Hamdani

2020

JP2WD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Chapter 7 was earlier accepted for publication as a co-authored chapter in the forthcoming book Shaping Regional Futures: Designing and Visioning in Governance Rescaling (Balz and Zonneveld, 2019). It investigates the organisational implications of perceiving regional design as a form of discretion.…”

Section: Research Approachmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Hoofdstuk 7 -De institutionalisering van een creatieve praktijk: Veranderende posities en rollen van regionaal ontwerp in de nationale planning in Nederland Hoofdstuk 7 is eerder geaccepteerd voor publicatie als een in samenwerking met een andere auteur geschreven hoofdstuk in het boek Shaping Regional Futures: Designing and Visioning in Governance Rescaling (Balz and Zonneveld, 2019). Het onderzoekt de organisatorische implicaties van het observeren van regionaal ontwerp als een vorm van discretie.…”

Section: Tocunclassified

“…-Chapter 7 -The institutionalisation of a creative practice: Changing positions and roles of regional design in Dutch national planning: An important implication of perceiving regional design as discretionary action is that that the involvement of actors in regional-design practice requires careful scrutiny. This chapter (Balz and Zonneveld, 2019), earlier accepted for publication in the forthcoming book Shaping Regional Futures: Designing and Visioning in Governance Rescaling, critically discusses the institutionalisation of regional design in Dutch national planning on the grounds of an analysis of repetitive actor constellations and the formalisation of regional design in Dutch planning and policies. Conclusions emphasise on a need for discernible actor constellations when regional design is used for the qualification of planning decisions.…”

Section: Structure Of the Thesismentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Regional Design

Balz

2019

Architecture and the Built Environment

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This dissertation would not have been possible without the support of the many people who were involved in it in direct or indirect ways.First and foremost I want to thank my two promotors. Wil Zonneveld, my main promotor, has accompanied my work consistently, patiently, and with much empathy. Without his curiosity for my practical experience, his extensive knowledge about the key concepts and context that my work is engaged with, his openness towards my evolving positions, and his enduring trust in my abilities to substantiate these, this thesis would not have been possible. Vincent Nadin, co-promotor, has inspired many of the decisive decisions I took during the dissertation, thanks to his concise and critical comments.I thank journal editors who helped this research by their reviews of the articles that form part of it. As this research evolved as an exploratory case-study analysis involving theory formation, their constructive and critical comments have played an particularly important part. I thank conference organisers, specifically the ones who have helped organize the Round Table at the AESOP conference 2014: Emerging regional design in an era of co-governance and co-evolution. I thank my fellow researchers who discussed and commented on my work during the course of the dissertation. My specific gratitude goes to Agnes Förster and Valeria Lingua. During our preparation of the conferences 'Shaping Regional Futures: Mapping, Designing, Transforming!' and 'Shaping Regional Futures: Designing and Visioning in Governance Rescaling' we had long and fruitful discussions on regional design. Together with Alain Thierstein and Giuseppe de Luca they hosted the conferences in Munich in October 2015 and Florence in May 2017. Both conferences were unique and, for me, very important opportunities for exchange. I also thank Andreas Faludi who has helped me structure my thoughts at critical stages of this research, and who has inspired me.I thank colleagues at TU Delft, with whom I could share experiences. I feel specific gratitude for Maurits de Hoog, who was my supervisor when I started at the Department of Urbanism. He provided me with intellectual freedom at the start of my dissertation. Without his generosity, this research would have taken another path, away from my own interests. I also thank Remon Rooij, who has supported me during the last stage of the work, as voluntary daily supervisor. TOC I want to thank my friends: Ellis ten Dam, for her extensive strategic advice on how to proceed during the ups and downs of this dissertation and her optimism about it; Dena Kasraian, for her always realistic estimation of where I was standing; Jelte Boeijenga, for reflecting with me on where this all could lead, Jorge Gil for his practical advice, and Leo van den Burg for being there. I thank my family. I thank Clemens and Lissy for hosting me during the most productive periods of this dissertation. I thank my sisters: Sabine, who encouraged me to be practical, and Bettina, who encouraged me to be ambitious. I thank my daug...

show abstract