The influence of vulnerability on migration intentions in Afghanistan

Abstract

This study explores the influence of vulnerability on migration intentions within the context of Afghanistan. While it is commonplace to conceptualize migration as being driven by certain economic-related factors, it is reasonable to assume that in an insecure setting like Afghanistan the difference between voluntary and involuntary movement is not easily distinguishable, making it necessary to approach the subject through a spectrum which does not presuppose migration is strictly economic in nature. With this in mind, we consider the issue through the broader lens of household vulnerability, a measure which incorporates a range of socio-economic factors allowing for a more comprehensive analysis. We first construct a profile of household vulnerability through individual indicators of deprivation along four principle dimensions, and then perform a regression analysis estimating the influence on migration intentions. Our results provide clear evidence that vulnerable households have a lower likelihood of concrete plans to migrate. This result supports the suggestion that it is not the "poorest of the poor", or in our case the "most vulnerable of the vulnerable" who aspire to move, indicating households have a realistic understanding of their capabilities taking into consideration the inherent costs and risks associated with cross-border movement.

Home is where the money goes: migration-related urban-rural integration in delta regions

“…In our theoretical framework migrants' capabilities and aspirations influence both motivations to remit as well as specific determinants of remittances. It should be noted that the most vulnerable do not necessarily have the greatest aspirations or capability to migrate (Loschmann & Siegel, 2014). For example, is many societies, including Bangladesh, a younger male is likely to have greater capabilities and aspirations to emigrate in order to support their family as compared to an older female.…”

Youth Migration Aspirations in Georgia and Moldova

“…Individuals lacking capital cannot afford to migrate but likewise financial insecurity can reduce one's 'capacity to aspire' (Carling, 2002;Carling & Schewel, 2017;Czaika & Vothknecht, 2014;de Haas, 2014;Horváth, 2008). Lower income and household vulnerability have been shown to reduce intentions to migrate (Czaika & Vothknecht, 2014;Loschmann & Siegel, 2013). New Economics of Labor Migration (NELM) states that households will diversify income sources based on risk in various markets (Massey et al, 2009;Stark & Bloom, 1985).…”

Youth with a Migrant Background: Are They Willing to Stay in Russia?

“…Among them, an extensive group of papers examines the medical personnel's migration intentions (Võrk, Kallaste, Priinits, 2004;Akl, et al, 2008;Imran, et al 2011;Freeman, et al 2012;George, Reardon, 2013;Gouda, et al, 2015). Researchers identify a number of factors related to migration plans and intentions: remittances (Leeves, 2009), the Internet (Vilhelmson, Thulin, 2013;Thulin, Vilhelmson, 2014), characteristics of the respondent's household compared to other households in the local community (Loschmann, Siegel, 2014), and violence against migrants in host countries (Friebel, Gallego, Mendola, 2013). A number of publications demonstrate the importance of age, as well as life stage and life events connected with it (Kley, Mulder, 2010;Elbadawy, 2011).…”