The Influence of Tissue Procurement Procedures on RNA Integrity, Gene Expression, and Morphology in Porcine and Human Liver Tissue

Abstract

The advent of molecular characterization of tissues has brought an increasing emphasis on the quality of biospecimens, starting with the tissue procurement process. RNA levels are particularly affected by factors in the collection process, but the influence of different pre-analytical factors is not well understood. Here we present the influence of tissue specimen size, as well as the transport and freezing protocols, on RNA quality. Large, medium, and smaller porcine liver samples were stored either dry, on moist gauze, or in salt solution for various times, and then frozen in either liquid nitrogen or in pre-cooled isopentane. Large and small human liver samples were frozen in pre-cooled isopentane either immediately or after one hour at room temperature. The small samples were stored dry, on moist gauze, or in salt solution. RNA was isolated and RIN values were measured. The RNA for six standard reference genes from human liver was analyzed by RT-qPCR, and tissue morphology was assessed for artifacts of freezing. Experiments using porcine liver samples showed that RNA derived from smaller samples was more degraded after one hour of cold ischemia, and that cooled transport is preferable. Human liver samples showed significant RNA degradation after 1 h of cold ischemia, which was more pronounced in smaller samples. RNA integrity was not significantly influenced by the transport or freezing method, but changes in gene expression were observed in samples either transported on gauze or in salt solution. Based on observations in liver samples, smaller samples are more subject to gene expression variability introduced by post-excision sample handling than are larger samples. Small biopsies should be transported on ice and snap frozen as soon as possible after acquisition from the patient.

Highly degraded RNA can still provide molecular information: An in vitro approach

“…Our data are then in agreement with the hypothesis that the long‐term survival of the RNA samples depends mainly on the protection against RNAase attacks rather than on environmental factors (such as humidity, acidity, etc. ), which are instead of great importance for DNA stability .…”

“…It is generally accepted that RNA is more labile than DNA and that RNA degradation occurs quite readily—in the postmortem period—in a tissue‐specific manner . Although conflicting results were obtained in studying the role of the postmortem period on RNA integrity, both endogenous and exogenous RNases are likely the main cause of this early process . In addition, even premortem factors (such as environmental conditions and circumstances of death) may influence the degree of RNA degradation .…”

Development and Validation of a Three-gene Prognostic Signature for Patients with Hepatocellular Carcinoma

“…Another point which is easy to be neglected but could have an impact is the tissue procurement procedures. The intra- and post-operative cold and warm ischemia were reported to impact the RNA 27 , protein 28 and metabolites 29 of clinical tissue specimens. The tissue procurement procedures can have a significant impact on the quality of specimens and might influence the reproducibility of analytical data sets for biomarker.…”

Differential amplicons (ΔAmp)—a new molecular method to assess RNA integrity

“…In established workflows in pathology tissues are treated with formalin and embedded in paraffin (FFPE), which preserves samples’ morphology but is deleterious to the RNA. These factors may profoundly influence measured expression levels leading to unreliable and in worst cases fatally incorrect results [17] . mRNA degradation is a particular severe problem when analysing tissues rich in RNases, such as pancreas and spleen.…”