The influence of cooperative education and reflection upon previous work experiences on university graduates’ vocational self-concept

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to assess the relative effects of participation in cooperative education (co-op) and engagement in reflection upon previous work experiences on undergraduate students’ vocational self-concept (VSC) at graduation. Design/methodology/approach – A cross-sectional survey of graduating students (n=1,483) from a Canadian university was used. Regression models and a mediation analysis were used to test the influence of co-op on VSC through the mechanism of reflection. Findings – Results suggest that both co-op and reflection on previous work experiences have direct effects on VSC, and that reflection partially mediates the relationship between degree type and VSC. Research limitations/implications – This supports the role of work-integrated learning and self-reflection as critical determinants of students’ work-related learning outcomes, and co-op as a potential container in which reflection may occur. Practical implications – Students should be given opportunity to reflect on their work-related experiences in order to strengthen their VSC. Institutions may integrate practices related to reflection in order for their students to reap the benefits of deeper learning. Originality/value – This study represents an inaugural view of the potential links between self-reflection and the development of students’ VSC across both co-op and non-co-op degree types.

Experiences of Food Insecurity Among Undergraduate Students: “You Can’t Starve Yourself Through School”

“…The location of the study (a university in southwestern Ontario) is unique in terms of the breadth of cooperative education, though many colleges and universities across Canada include work placements or internships in undergraduate and graduate degree curricula (Rodriguez, Zhao, & Ferguson, 2016). Co-op programs have been found to enhance self-efficacy and confidence and contribute to student retention (Drewery, Nevison, & Pretti, 2016;Newhook, 2016). However, although our sample is small, students expressed that uncertainty regarding co-op income and expenses exacerbated financial instability.…”

The alumni narrative of the connection between university skills and knowledge, and industry: An ‘outside-in’ understanding

“…For instance, WIL and internship curriculum-based programs have been well documented in helping students develop clear expectations of industry work, soft-skill development, networking and building students' general confidence (Elijido & Kloot, 2015;Drewery et al, 2016;Jackson, 2017). Along with studying specific outcomes of curriculum-based experiences (i.e.…”

“…While there was mention of structured, curriculum-based WIL and placement experiences within the literature (e.g. Elijido & Kloot, 2015;Drewery et al, 2016;Jackson, 2017), findings indicated any type of work experience, including volunteering, was key in preparing to transition to professional work.…”

Supervisory Practices in a Virtual Internship Program: A Multi-Case Study

“…As such, the transformation a student's experience may be facilitated by opportunities to reflect on the impact of an internship on occupational choices. The positive connection between an internship and enhanced vocational selfconcept has been reported as further evidence that reflecting on work experience better prepares students for the career industry (Drewery, Nevison, & Pretti, 2016). Stichman and Farkas (2005) conducted a nationwide study on internships in undergraduate criminal justice programs and found the major strength of an internship to be the student's' ability to integrate theory and practice.…”

“…Research supports the value that internships hold in helping students become aware of their vocational attributes. (Taylor, 1988;Drewery et al, 2016).…”