The Influence of Community Health Resources on Effectiveness and Sustainability of Community and Lay Health Worker Programs in Lower-Income Countries: A Systematic Review

Abstract

BackgroundDespite the availability of practical knowledge and effective interventions required to reduce priority health problems in low-income countries, poor and vulnerable populations are often not reached. One possible solution to this problem is the use of Community or Lay Health Workers (CLHWs). So far, however, the development of sustainability in CLHW programs has failed and high attrition rates continue to pose a challenge. We propose that the roles and interests which support community health work should emerge directly from the way in which health is organized at community level. This review explores the evidence available to assess if increased levels of integration of community health resources in CLHW programs indeed lead to higher program effectiveness and sustainability.Methods and FindingsThis review includes peer-reviewed articles which meet three eligibility criteria: 1) specific focus on CLHWs or equivalent; 2) randomized, quasi-randomized, before/after methodology or substantial descriptive assessment; and 3) description of a community or peer intervention health program located in a low- or middle-income country. Literature searches using various article databases led to 2930 hits, of which 359 articles were classified. Of these, 32 articles were chosen for extensive review, complemented by analysis of the results of 15 other review studies. Analysis was conducted using an excel based data extraction form. Because results showed that no quantitative data was published, a descriptive synthesis was conducted. The review protocol was not proactively registered. Findings show minimal inclusion of even basic community level indicators, such as the degree to which the program is a community initiative, community input in the program or training, the background and history of CLHW recruits, and the role of the community in motivation and retention. Results show that of the 32 studies, only one includes one statistical measure of community integration. As a result of this lack of data we are unable to derive an evidence-based conclusion to our propositions. Instead, our results indicate a larger problem, namely the complete absence of indicators measuring community relationships with the programs studied. Studies pay attention only to gender and peer roles, along with limited demographic information about the recruits. The historicity of the health worker and the community s/he belongs to is absent in most studies reviewed. None of the studies discuss or test for the possibility that motivation emanates from the community. Only a few studies situate attrition and retention as an issue enabled by the community. The results were limited by a focus on low-income countries and English, peer-reviewed published articles only.ConclusionPublished, peer-reviewed studies evaluating the effectiveness and sustainability of CLHW interventions in health programs have not yet adequately tested for the potential of utilizing existing community health roles or social networks for the development of effective and sus...

A systematic review of randomized trials for engaging socially disadvantaged groups in health research: A distillation approach

“…Out of the few studies we found that used randomized controlled experiments to test recruitment and retention strategies, almost all had high or unclear risk of bias. Additionally, strategies previously touted as important to increasing participation, such as increasing trust (Corbie-Smith, Thomas, Williams, & Moody-Ayers, 1999;Ford, Havstad, & Davis, 2004;Fracasso et al, 2013;Gwadz et al, 2014) , did not differentiate between "winning" and "ineffective" interventions while research process-related strategies (e.g. systematic contact plan) did.…”

“…the availability of contraceptives is everywhere.”: Coordinated Family Planning Service Delivery in Rwanda Facilitates Integration of Family Planning into Other Health Services

“…CHW programs have been implemented in many different nations around the world with varying degrees of success (2). A number of characteristics of the Rwandan CHW program arose in this research that have been considered integral to successful CHW programs in the literature: CHWs live in and are selected by their neighbors for their role, they have frequent interactions with and are well-respected by members of their communities -which serves as the most important method of supervision, and the links between CHWs and the formal health sector is strong (2,3,6,26). The success of the Rwandan CHW program could ultimately be due to government support and respect of CHWs that sets up the pathways associated with successful CHW programs (22,26).…”

“…One route to increasing access to primary care for all persons, particularly for populations hardest to reach, is via community health worker (CHW) programs (2). CHW programs provide primary comprehensive healthcare in the community (3), and extant research shows that the most effective programs have CHWs who are elected members of the communities that they serve (2). Despite some challenges identi ed in sustaining CHW programs, research thus far suggests that CHWs are a worthy investment for public health (1,4).…”

Environmental Health Research in Africa: Important Progress and Promising Opportunities

“…Occupational exposures were another important source of ambient air pollution exposure. Activities included limestone processing in Zambia (Bwalya et al, 2011), exposure to desert dust in West Africa [reviewed by de Longueville et al (2013)], traffic exhaust (DeMarini, 2013), dust and fumes in artisanal mining (Ekosse, 2011), city transit-related air pollution Ekpenyong et al, 2012), stone quarrying industry exposures including deposition of inhaled aerosol particles at an industrial site in Egypt (Furi et al, 2017), sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions from platinum group metal (PGM) smelting in Zimbabwe (Gwimbi, 2017), and charcoal processing activities in Namibia, including exposure to charcoal dust (Hamatui et al, 2016). DNA adducts to measure air pollution exposure among urban and suburban residents was also implemented in some studies (Ayi-Fanou et al, 2011).…”

“…Developments in pharmacogenomics (Warnich et al, 2011) and the human microbiome (Adebamowo et al, 2017) are also underway, and many studies incorporate information about HIV, malaria, tuberculosis, and other common infections in Africa. The H3Africa consortium also promotes opportunities for training in bioinformatics (Adoga et al, 2014;Oluwagbemi et al, 2014;Mulder et al, 2016), supports three biorepositories on the African continent, and facilitates policy and ethical recommendations (Consortium et al, 2014;Barchi and Little, 2016;Munung et al, 2016;de Vries and Pool, 2017).…”