The Importance of Direct Experience: A Philosophical Defence of Fieldwork in Human Geography

Abstract

Human geography fieldwork is important. Research has shown that when students 'see it for themselves' their enjoyment and understanding is enhanced. In addition it helps develop subject-specific and transferable skills, promotes 'active learning' and links theory to 'real world' examples in a 'spiral of learning'. Stressing the socially constructed nature of knowledge and identity, however, Nairn (2005) has made a valuable critique of the assumption that human geography fieldwork gives students direct and unmediated access to 'the truth'. Drawing on qualitative research with students in New Zealand she shows that their fieldwork experience, rather than enhancing their understanding, reinforced misconceptions they held prior to the trip. Using evidence from an action research project on the student experience of human geography fieldwork in the Western Isles of Scotland, this paper argues that while fieldwork can reinforce preconceptions in the way Nairn describes, this is not inevitably so. Fieldwork can give us direct experiences that challenge our preconceptions. The reality of others can 'call us to attention' in ways that make them matter to us. This 'enhanced affective response' helps deepen our understanding of the wider world and our place within it. It is for this reason that fieldwork remains a valuable mode of learning for human geography students.

Emotional Engagement and Active Learning in a Marketing Simulation: A Review and Exploratory Study

“…It is suggested that active learning can create an enhanced affective response [14]. This is supported by the findings of Ref.…”

“…So as such the operation and interaction with the simulation generated this aporia. As such the engagement of emotions "negatively" in the above scenario was found to be a vehicle to utilise this important dimension of learning [27] and to generate attentiveness to enrich understanding [14]. As an artefact the simulation was noticeably generative of this situation which would not have occurred in a traditional lecture format.…”

“…Whilst Ref. [14] asserts that active learning can generate a positive emotional response that instigates an "attentiveness that enriches understanding" and which can enhance self-esteem and a sense of empowerment [17]. There is, however, little research that investigates the effect of negative emotional response and its impact on attentiveness that enriches understanding.…”

“…[28] suggested that computer technology such as simulations can be used to create authentic assessments that mirror real world scenarios. Related to active learning is the generation of deep learning as a result of the simulated experience and linking a taught theory such as segmentation, targeting and positioning (STP) to the "real" world resulting in the challenging of preconceptions [14]. According to Ref.…”

Types of learning identified in reflective energy diaries of post-graduate students

“…The challenge-and therefore the value-of fieldwork is said to emerge from a direct, active encounter with Bthe other^ (Hope 2009). The focus of this paper concerns the role of fieldwork in promoting learning about energy amongst students within their own homes, i.e.…”