We investigate the effect of gas diffusion media (GDM) porosity on open-cathode fuel cell operation in challenging ambient air conditions known to exacerbate either cell dehydration or liquid water saturation. A less porous cathode GDM improves cell contact that decreases interfacial contact resistances. We relate structural properties of the cathode GDM to heat rejection, oxygen transport, and water management in the open-cathode fuel cell using polarization behavior and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. Less porous cathode GDM reduce the measured cell temperature at the cathode surface and decrease ohmic resistance by >33% at 0.6 V, increasing current density from 0.197 to 0.299 mA cm −2 . Small decreases in cathode GDM porosity considerably improve thermal management, cell hydration, cathode charge transfer, and decrease ohmic resistance, increasing current density and power production despite concomitant increases in mass transport resistance.