The impacts of habitat disturbance on adult and larval dragonflies (Odonata) in rainforest streams in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo

Abstract

SUMMARY1. Dragonfly assemblages (Odonata: comprising damselflies, Zygoptera; and dragonflies, Anisoptera) in Southeast Asian rainforests are extremely diverse but increasingly threatened by habitat disturbance, including logging and conversion of forest to oil palm plantations. 2. Land-use change can affect dragonfly larval stages by altering within-stream environmental conditions, and adults by loss of perches, shade and hunting habitat. However, the extent to which dragonflies are affected by land-use change is not well known, and strategies for conservation are poorly developed. 3. We surveyed dragonfly adults and larvae, forest quality and stream environmental conditions across 16 streams in Sabah, Malaysia. Habitat surrounding the streams included pristine forest, selectively logged forest, oil palm with forested riparian buffer strips and oil palm without buffers. 4. Overall abundance and species richness of adult dragonflies stayed constant with habitat disturbance, but larval abundance and richness decreased with higher habitat disturbance, and larvae were largely absent from oil palm streams. There was also a clear shift in community composition of both adult and larval dragonflies. Anisoptera adults were more species rich and abundant, but Zygoptera adults were less species rich in more disturbed sites. 5. The presence of riparian buffers in oil palm plantations offered some protection for forest-associated dragonfly species, and streams with wider riparian buffers supported adult assemblages more similar to those found in logged forest. However, oil palm streams with riparian buffers still contained a depauperate larval assemblage compared to logged forest areas, and dragonfly assemblages in narrow riparian buffer streams were similar to those found in streams surrounded by continuous oil palm. 6. Our results provide clear evidence of the effect of land-use change on dragonflies. Conservation efforts to conserve forest communities should target the preservation of existing forest areas, but management within oil palm plantation landscapes to preserve riparian buffers can still have a marked beneficial effect on dragonfly communities.

Movement of moths through riparian reserves within oil palm plantations

“…In contrast, for dung beetles, we found that for several species they were unable to penetrate the oil palm matrix and preferentially used the riparian reserves to move within the matrix landscape and between forests. Our findings have implications for setaside forest within oil palm landscapes and support the growing evidence base that contiguous riparian forest corridors are essential for maintaining biodiversity for many invertebrate taxa (Barlow et al, 2010, Gray et al 2016, Luke et al 2017, Scriven et al 2017. The copyright holder for this preprint (which was not .…”

To what extent can oil palm plantations in the Amazon support assemblages of Odonata larvae?

“…In oil palm plantations in Malaysia, the environmental integrity and diversity of aquatic biota are affected by soil conditions and land use within their drainage basins; thus, there is a need to include and manage riparian buffers in streams of oil palm areas (Mercer et al ., ; Luke et al ., 2017a). In Brazil, the Forest Code – Law 4.771/65 – determines that water bodies in plantation areas must maintain forested buffers, which are called Permanent Preservation Areas (PPAs).…”

Oil palm and biodiversity: a situation analysis by the IUCN Oil Palm Task Force

“…Streams flowing through plantations and other cleared areas are warmer, shallower, have more sand and reduced abundance of species such as dragonflies (210,211), although flood-control channels can serve as habitat for some water birds in oil palm areas (212).…”

“…Fish and stream macroinvertebrates in protected streams are typically more similar in composition to those found in pristine forests than unprotected streams in farmland (210,344,345). For example, species that use leaf litter and coarse substrate for hiding and foraging were found to be missing from oil palm sites that did not have riparian reserves (345).…”