The impact of religious affiliation on trust in the context of electronic commerce

Abstract

There is currently a growing literature on the role that trust plays in encouraging consumers to engage in e-commerce transactions. Various models have been proposed which aim to identify both the antecedents and outcomes of trust displayed towards e-commerce web sites.Increased trust is generally shown to increase positive user attitude which in turn is linked to increased willingness to buy. Studies have shown the antecedents of trust include variables such as the perceived reputation and size of the vendor organisation. The current paper explores the role of cultural variables as antecedents of trust with the main emphasis being on religious affiliation. Participants recruited from Christian, Muslim and other faiths were asked to interact with online bookstores identified as Christian, Muslim or Neutral. Trust and attitudes towards the web sites were measured and this data was used to test the hypothesis that same-religion sites would be trusted and liked more than other religion or neutral sites.This hypothesis was partially supported, but only for the Muslim participants. It was found that the Muslim group expressed significantly more trust in the Muslim site compared to the Christian site. They also expressed significantly more positive attitudes towards the Muslim online bookstore than the other two sites. The implications of these result for theories of web based trust and attitude are discussed along with the practical implications of the findings.

The Effect of Religious Identity on User Judgment of Website Quality

“…People may be separating evaluation of usability and aesthetics from identity and treating them objectively. Respondents favored matching identity websites and evaluated them more favorably than websites from other religions (both Muslims and Christians); which partially agrees with Siala et al [8] results that only Muslims trusted matching identity websites while Christians favored neutral websites. Brand affected respondents' judgment of content, service quality, usability and aesthetics which agrees with De Angeli et al [4] who demonstrated that people who have positive attitudes towards the website brand were more positive in the evaluation of aesthetics, pleasure and usability.…”

Knowing What a User Likes: A Design Science Approach to Interfaces that Automatically Adapt to Culture

“…This finding has been also shown to impact the center of attention on a screen, suggesting that error messages and important interface elements should be placed according to the start location of a person's writing system orientation (Röse 2005). Another cultural influence is religion, which is often named as a mediator of preferences for certain symbols and colors, and implicitly the feeling of trust (Siala et al 2004). Furthermore, varying education levels contribute to the creation of cultural groups, so-called "subcultures" (Karahanna et al 2005).…”

Improving performance, perceived usability, and aesthetics with culturally adaptive user interfaces

“…In addition, there are many aspects of culture that have been found to impact interface preferences, such as a user's first (and second) language [Nisbett 2003;Röse 2005], religion [Siala et al 2004], the education level and the form of education. For example, people who have mostly received teacher-centered instruction are more likely to appreciate detailed instructions later in life [Reinecke 2005], and this seems to be a decisive factor for the self-determined handling of computers.…”