The Impact of Race and Gender-Related Discrimination on the Psychological Distress Experienced by Junior Doctors in the UK: A Qualitative Secondary Data Analysis

Abstract

Almost half of NHS doctors are junior doctors, while high proportions are women and/or Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic (BAME) individuals. Discrimination against this population is associated with poorer career-related outcomes and unequal representation. We aimed to qualitatively explore junior doctors’ experience of workplace racial and gender-based discrimination, and its impact on their psychological distress (PD). In this study, we carried out a secondary analysis of data from a UK-based parent study about junior doctors’ working cultures and conditions. Interview data was examined using thematic analysis. Transcripts (n = 14) documenting experiences of race and/or gender-based discrimination were sampled and analysed from 21 in-depth interviews conducted with UK junior doctors. Four themes were generated about the experiences and perpetrators of discrimination, the psychological impact of discrimination, and organisational interventions that tackle discrimination. Discrimination in various forms was reported, from racially charged threats to subtle microaggressions. Participants experienced profoundly elevated levels of PD, feeling fearful, undermined, and under-confident. Discrimination is associated with elevated levels of PD, whilst negatively impacting workforce sustainability and retention. This reduces the opportunity for more diversity in NHS medical leadership. We encourage NHS hospitals to review their policies about discrimination and develop in-person workshops that focus on recognising, challenging, and reporting workplace discrimination.

From the Frying Pan to the Fire - Life as a Foundation Year One

“…On the other side, ethnic minority doctors also experience challenges in career progression, including systemic biases, workplace discrimination, and a lack of representation in leadership roles 5 . These disparities not only hinder the full potential of the healthcare system but also undermine the trust and confidence of both patients and doctors.…”

Factors associated with suicide in physicians: a silent stigma and public health problem that has not been studied in depth

“…Unfortunately, physicians commonly report gender discrimination, which significantly impacts the affected person’s performance and quality of life. In the United Kingdom, Hussain et al ( 35 ) qualitatively analyzed this phenomenon and found that affected individuals reported suffering from high levels of stress, fear, mistrust, low resilience, and retention. These microaggressions, harassment, or discrimination against women can be observed in regions with questionable medical professionalism, underestimating their potential and skills in practice.…”