The Impact of Personality and Culture on the Job Demands-Control Model of Job Stress

Abstract

Abstract. Among the various work stress models, one of the most popular has been the job demands-control (JDC) model developed by Karasek (1979), which postulates that work-related strain is highest under work conditions characterized by high demands and low autonomy. The absence of social support at work further increases negative outcomes. This model, however, does not apply equally to all individuals and to all cultures. This review demonstrates how various individual characteristics, especially some personality dimensions, influence the JDC model and could thus be considered buffering or moderator factors. Moreover, we review how the cultural context impacts this model as suggested by results obtained in European, American, and Asian contexts. Yet there are almost no data from Africa or South America. More crosscultural studies including populations from these continents would be valuable for a better understanding of the impact of the cultural context on the JDC model.

Are the Effects of Work-related Extended Availability the Same for Everyone?

“…While there is at least some evidence for moderator effects of segmentation preferences on the relationship between WREA and relevant outcome variables, there is virtually none for personality traits, which is astonishing given that personality strongly impacts how employees experience work demands and whether they feel strained by them (Györkös et al, 2012). Personality traits influence emotion regulation strategies (Kokkonen & Pulkkinen, 2001), coping behaviors (Connor-Smith & Flachsbart, 2007), and how people respond to external stimuli (Bolger & Schilling, 1991).…”

Validation of the French Utrecht Work Engagement Scale and its relationship with personality traits and impulsivity

“…Even though personality traits predict several important work outcomes, the strength of these relationships is a function of the outcome considered, of the complexity of the work activity, and of the work context (Barrick & Mount, 2012). In further studies, the buffering role of personality on the relationship between situational and environmental factors and well-being at work may be valuable to investigate, as well as taking into account the role of culture (Györkos, Becker, Massoudi, de Bruin, & Rossier, 2012).…”

Do Job Demands of Chinese Manufacturing Employees Predict Positive or Negative Outcomes? A Test of Competing Hypotheses

“…For example, some of the Chinese traditional cultural values that originated from Confucian social ethics differ notably from those of Western societies, such as respect for authority, fatalism and a sense of powerlessness (Xie et al, ). Although a recent cross‐cultural JDC model review suggested that the model is generalizable across cultures, including China (Györkös, Becker, Massoudi, de Bruin, & Rossier, ), an extensive literature review of previous JDC studies using non‐Western blue‐collar samples (e.g. manufacturers) yielded mixed results.…”