The Impact of Microenvironmental Heterogeneity on the Evolution of Drug Resistance in Cancer Cells

Abstract

Therapeutic resistance arises as a result of evolutionary processes driven by dynamic feedback between a heterogeneous cell population and environmental selective pressures. Previous studies have suggested that mutations conferring resistance to epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI) in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cells lower the fitness of resistant cells relative to drug-sensitive cells in a drug-free environment. Here, we hypothesize that the local tumor microenvironment could influence the magnitude and directionality of the selective effect, both in the presence and absence of a drug. Using a combined experimental and computational approach, we developed a mathematical model of preexisting drug resistance describing multiple cellular compartments, each representing a specific tumor environmental niche. This model was parameterized using a novel experimental dataset derived from the HCC827 erlotinib-sensitive and -resistant NSCLC cell lines. We found that, in contrast to in the drug-free environment, resistant cells may hold a fitness advantage compared to parental cells in microenvironments deficient in oxygen and nutrients. We then utilized the model to predict the impact of drug and nutrient gradients on tumor composition and recurrence times, demonstrating that these endpoints are strongly dependent on the microenvironment. Our interdisciplinary approach provides a model system to quantitatively investigate the impact of microenvironmental effects on the evolutionary dynamics of tumor cells.

A mathematical approach to differentiate spontaneous and induced evolution to drug resistance during cancer treatment

“…Mathematical modeling studies in particular have been used to explore both broad and detailed aspects of cancer drug resistance, as reviewed in [43,7,25]. The fundamental question of how the presence of drug resistant cells influences tumor dynamics and treatment outcomes has been thoroughly explored in mathematical models under a wide variety of assumptions [14,37,39,47,58,40,23,24,70,16,45,60,63,4,22,33,44,52,65,3,32,80,13,26,29,46,49,51,57,59,77,18,68,1,9,10,20]. Cancer models have also been utilized to assess how various underlying mechanisms contribute to the resistant phenotype [80,13,59,18,20], and to calculate the probability that drug resistance emerges within a specified time frame, be it before or during cancer treatment …”

“…As examples, pre-existing BCR-ABL kinase domain mutations confer resistance to the tyrosine kinase inhibitor imatinib in chronic myeloid leukemia patients [66,36], and pre-existing MEK1 mutations confer resistance to BRAF inhibitors in melanoma patients [8]. Many mathematical models have considered how the presence of preexisting resistant cells impact cancer progression and treatment [37,39,58,40,23,24,70,16,60,63,4,22,44,3,32,80,29,49,57,59,77,68,9,10].On the other hand, acquired drug resistance broadly describes the case in which drug resistance develops during the course of therapy from a population of cells that were initially drug sensitive [34]. The term "acquired resistance" is really an umbrella term for two distinct phenomena, which complicates the study of acquired resistance.…”

Leveraging Hypoxia-Activated Prodrugs to Prevent Drug Resistance in Solid Tumors

“…In [2], this dependence was quantified by obtaining live/dead cell counts for isogenic HCC827 sensitive and resistant (harboring the T790M resistance mutation) cell lines in vitro at varying concentrations of oxygen and drug. We then calculated birth and death rates as functions of oxygen and erlotinib concentration using an exponential growth model.…”

Evolution of Drug Resistance in Bacteria

“…High levels of resistance are typically mediated by genes that code enzymes degrading or pumping out the drug (Finch 2012). Such genes are often acquired from other microbial species in the process of gene exchange.…”

“…This gives our discussion a more general flavour. In fact, many analogies exist between AMR and resistance to cancer chemotherapy , and theoretical models similar to discussed in this chapter have been applied to cancerous tumours (Foo et al 2015;Fu et al 2014) and viral infections (Moreno-Gamez et al 2014). …”