The Impact of Malpractice Claims on Physicians’ Well-Being and Practice

Abstract

Objectives: Malpractice litigation causes extreme stress. We examine the psychological impact of malpractice claims on physicians' well-being and the consequences on patient care. Methods:A confidential telephone survey, administered to physicians with both open and closed claims from the previous year, explored symptoms, well-being changes, needs, impairments, and practice changes.Results: Of the 282 respondents, more than half (56.38%) reported a notable psychological reaction to the malpractice claim, with no differences between the open and closed claims (P = 0.2477) or between closed claims with and without a payout (P = 1). Physicians facing criminal proceedings were more likely to experience a notable psychological impact (P = 0.0206). Almost half of the respondents (45.39%) acknowledged practice changes: viewing patients as potential plaintiffs (45.39%), paying more attention to recordkeeping (42.19%), obtaining medicolegal training (37.94%), ordering more tests (36.17%), and avoiding specific kinds of patients (21.63%) or procedures (19.85%). Acknowledging a psychological impact was positively and significantly associated with professional practice changes (P < 0.0001), and the mean number of symptoms was significantly higher among those who acknowledged practice changes (P = 0.0001).Conclusions: Our results confirm the psychological impact of a malpractice claim and that impacted physicians are more likely to change their care practices, involving defensive medicine practices. Therefore, care for physicians facing malpractice claims needs to be considered under the umbrella of health care quality. Timely mental health referral paths could help mitigate the psychological impact and avoid the pernicious effects of negative practice changes.

Vocational and psychosocial predictors of medical negligence claims among Australian doctors: a prospective cohort analysis of the MABEL survey

“… 24 This is particularly important because we know from numerous studies that being sued can negatively impact on doctors’ health and well-being. 25 Therefore, it is imperative to intervene early to prevent poor doctor health leading to claims that can then further compromise doctors’ health.…”

“…For example, healthy lifestyle and positive psychology interventions can boost doctors’ subjective well-being, enhance patients’ perceptions of doctors’ empathy and improve clinical outcomes 24. This is particularly important because we know from numerous studies that being sued can negatively impact on doctors’ health and well-being 25. Therefore, it is imperative to intervene early to prevent poor doctor health leading to claims that can then further compromise doctors’ health.…”

Medical Liability: Review of a Whole Year of Judgments of the Civil Court of Rome

“…Furthermore, it was highlighted that to be involved in a legal action may be stressful for the healthcare professional (also due to the length of the judicial process), who may suffer damage to his/her reputation and a loss of trust in the physicians’ own performance by other patients [ 14 ].…”

How defensive medicine is defined in European medical literature: a systematic review

“…The studies were published during 1972–2021. Among those, the 50 European studies included in this systematic review2 3 5–8 16–20 22–25 34–68 were published during 1995–2020 with a steep increase in publications during the recent years (table 1, figure 2).…”