The Impact of Interpersonal Patient and Therapist Behavior on Outcome in Cognitive-Behavior Therapy

Abstract

Empirical studies are reviewed, the aim being to investigate characteristics of the therapeutic relationship in cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and to identify therapist or patient interpersonal behavior that affects treatment outcome. CBT is characterized by a more active and directive stance on the part of the therapists and higher levels of emotional support than are found in insight-oriented psychotherapies. Therapists express high levels of empathy and unconditional positive regard, similar to those expressed by insight-oriented psychotherapists. Two clusters of interpersonal behavior have been identified that are clearly associated with CBT outcome: (a) the Rogerian therapist variables--empathy, nonpossessive warmth, positive regard, and genuineness; and (b) therapeutic alliance. There is some evidence for the impact on outcome of three additional clusters of patient behavior: (a) the patients' perception of the therapist as being self-confident, skillful, and active; (b) the patients' openness to discuss their problems; and (c) the patients' pretreatment predisposition to change and to accept psychological treatment as a means of achieving this. It is further concluded that relationship factors in general have a consistent but moderate impact on CBT outcome.

“I Thought There Was No Hope for Me”: A Behavioral Intervention for Urban Mothers With Problem Drinking

“…Although the intervention manual clearly articulated a collaborative, guided discovery approach to the real-world application of skills, mothers interviewed for this qualitative study appeared to remember, with some detail, specific advice from their facilitators, which they perceived as extremely helpful and not coercive. Cognitive-behavioral therapists are typically directive with clients, and positive treatment outcomes have been associated with clients' perception of cognitive-behavioral therapists' being active, skillful, and self-confident in sessions (Keijsers, Schaap, & Hoogduin, 2000). Although we did not analyze the sessions that were recorded for supervision, this unexpected finding is an avenue for future research.…”

A Theoretical Model of Common Process Factors in Youth and Family Therapy

“…It also has been suggested that if a therapist uses too many of these directive behaviors, that this will negatively affect ratings of the counselors interpersonal skills (warmth, empathy, etc. ), however, this has not typically been found in the adult treatment literature (Keijsers, Schaap, & Hoogduin, 2000). In addition, McKay, Stoewe, McCadam, and Gonzales (1998) found that therapist active engagement strategies with families, such as explaining the helping process, actively focusing conversation onto immediate and practical concerns, and directly addressing barriers to treatment, resulted in greater family retention into treatment.…”

A review and critical appraisal of measures of therapist-patient interactions in mental health settings

“…For behaviour therapists, their relationship is good when they are effective and influential. 67,103 This process is linked to social influence theory: 91 the ability of the therapist to influence the patient on the basis of social power. Influence is also linked to the credibility of the therapist.…”