The Impact of Edema and Fiber Crossing on Diffusion MRI Metrics: DBSI vs. Diffusion ODF

Abstract

PurposeDiffusion tensor imaging (DTI) has been employed for over two decades to noninvasively quantify central nervous system (CNS) diseases/injuries. However, DTI is an inadequate simplification of diffusion modeling in the presence of co-existing inflammation, edema, and crossing nerve fibers. MethodsWe employed a tissue phantom using fixed mouse trigeminal nerves coated with various amounts of agarose gel to mimic crossing fibers in the presence of vasogenic edema. Diffusivity measures derived by DTI and diffusion basis spectrum imaging (DBSI) were compared at increasing levels of simulated edema and degrees of fiber crossing. Further, we assessed the ability of DBSI, diffusion kurtosis imaging (DKI), generalized q-sampling imaging (GQI), q-ball imaging (QBI), and neurite orientation dispersion and density imaging (NODDI) to resolve fiber crossing, in reference to the gold standard angles measured from structural images. ResultsDTI-computed diffusivities and fractional anisotropy (FA) were significantly confounded by gelmimicked edema and crossing fibers. Conversely, DBSI calculated accurate diffusivities of individual fibers regardless of the extent of simulated edema and degrees of fiber crossing angles. Additionaly, DBSI accurately and consistently estimated crossing angles in various conditions of gel-mimicked edema when comparing with gold standard (r 2 =0.92, p=1.9×10 -9 , bias=3.9°). Small crossing angles and edema sinficantly impact dODF, making DKI, GQI and QBI less accurate in detecting and estimating fibers corrsing angles. Lastly, we demonstrate DBSI's superiority over DTI for recovering and delineating white matter tracts in peritumoral edema for preoperative planning of surgical resection. ConclusionsDBSI is able to separate two crossing fibers and accurately recover their diffusivities in a complex environment characterized by increasing crossing angles and amounts of gel-mimicked edema. DBSI also indicated better angular resolution capability compared with DKI, QBI and GQI.

Deep Learning Improves Pre-Surgical White Matter Visualization in Glioma Patients

“…Consequently, accurate depiction of white matter tracts is important, especially those in close proximity to the tumor or passing within the plane of approach. Tensor-based techniques have been shown to be less reliable than non-tensor techniques at reproducing fiber tracts passing through, or near to aberrant or edematous structures 1,[5][6][7][24][25][26] . Peri-tumoral DTI tracts may therefore appear to terminate abruptly, be thinned, or be entirely absent 5,7 .…”

“…Common pre-surgical tractography techniques employ single-shell diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) acquisition protocols 1 . DTI is known to possess several critical limitations, however, potentially affecting the quality of tractography results [2][3][4] .…”

Analyzing the effects of free water modeling by deep learning on diffusion MRI structural connectivity estimates in glioma patients

“…Instead of assuming a fixed diffusivity of compartments, in recent publications the isotropic compartments is fitted using a spectrum of diffusivities. Modeling vasogenic edema with agarose gel, those multicompartment models can be verified in-vitro [15,16].…”