The impact of cattle ranching on large‐scale vegetation patterns in a coastal savanna in Tanzania

Abstract

Summary1. The success of large-scale cattle ranching in African savanna vegetation has often been limited by problems of bush encroachment and disease (in particular trypanosomiasis spread by tsetse flies). Mkwaja Ranch, occupying an area of 462 km 2 on the coast of Tanzania, is a recent example of a large ranching enterprise that failed within the savanna environment. It was closed in 2000 after 48 years of operation. In this paper we describe the main vegetation types of the area (excluding closed forest vegetation) and relate their patterns of distribution to the former use of the ranch for cattle. 2. The study area comprised the former ranch and parts of the adjacent Saadani Game Reserve, which had not been grazed by cattle for many years and had never been used for large-scale ranching. Following field surveys, 15 distinct types of grassland and bush vegetation were defined and a vegetation map was created using a Landsat TM satellite image. A multispectral classification using the maximum likelihood algorithm gave good results and enabled all 15 vegetation types to be distinguished on the map. 3. Two main spatial trends were detected in the vegetation. One was a large-scale decrease in the cover of bushland from the most intensively used parts of the ranch through more extensively used areas to the game reserve; this trend was attributed to differences in management history as well as to climatic and topographic factors. A second trend was a radial vegetation pattern associated with the enclosures where cattle were herded at night. High amounts of three bushland types [dominated by (i) Acacia zanzibarica , (ii) Dichrostachys cinerea , Acacia nilotica or Acacia mellifera and (iii) Terminalia spinosa ] occurred in a zone between 300 and 2500 m from the paddocks, with a peak in bush density at about 900 m (mean value for 18 paddocks). In contrast, bushland dominated by Hyphaene compressa was scarce close to the paddocks and became more abundant with distance. There was also a radial trend in the grassland communities: close to the paddocks there was short grass vegetation containing many ruderals and invasive weedy species, while the tall grassland types with species such as Hyperthelia dissoluta and Cymbopogon caesius occurred further away in the areas less affected by cattle. 4. Synthesis and applications. The intensive modern livestock ranching as practised on Mkwaja Ranch proved to be unsustainable both economically and ecologically. In the end, the biggest problem faced by the ranch managers was not controlling disease, as had originally been feared, but preventing the spread of bush on pasture land. The results of our study demonstrate just how severe the problem of bush encroachment was, especially in areas close to paddocks. An important lesson for management is that grazing patterns need to be taken into consideration when determining the sustainable stocking rate for an area. To reduce the risk of bush encroachment in grazing systems with focal points such as paddocks or watering points, stocking ra...

Tree size and herbivory determine below-canopy grass quality and species composition in savannahs

“…By avoiding predators, prey species can shape the habitat vegetation structure of their refuge area (Ripple and Beschta 2004). Bush-encroached areas are usually composed of small trees at high densities (Jeltsch et al 1997;Tobler et al 2003). In addition to their structural disadvantage of poor visibility, our study showed that small trees do not contribute as much to the structural and nutritional quality of the beneath-crown grass layer as large trees do.…”

“…Low recruitment rates of large tree species have also been reported by Holdo (2003) and Caro et al (2005). In addition, open savannahs become denser due to bush encroachment which is often the result of landscapes being over-grazed (Jeltsch et al 1997;Tobler et al 2003) and because of poor fire management (Eckhardt et al 2000). Since bush-encroached areas are mostly dominated by small and densely growing trees, tree size might be important in influencing grass quality and structure.…”

Conserving Wildlife in African Landscapes Kenya’s Ewaso Ecosystem

“…Shifts from grassland to shrubland may be related to changes in climate (Polley et al, 1997;Morgan et al, 2007), fire frequency and grazing intensity Roques et al, 2001;Tobler et al, 2003), and browsing pressure . In some areas of Africa, woodlands have declined in protected areas coincident with a concentration of elephants into these areas (e.g., Laws, 1970;Van de Vijver et al, 1999).…”

“…In some areas of Africa, woodlands have declined in protected areas coincident with a concentration of elephants into these areas (e.g., Laws, 1970;Van de Vijver et al, 1999). Conversely, woodland expansion is often observed in African rangelands managed for cattle production (Scholes and Archer, 1997;Oba et al, 2000;Roques et al, 2001;Tobler et al, 2003). A consequence of lowered tree or shrub densities may be increased availability of understory nutrients (Treydte et al, 2007), whereas increased densities of trees and shrubs can negatively affect grass productivity (Scholes and Archer, 1997;Smit and Rethman, 2000).…”

Community Structure and Productivity in Western Mongolian Steppe

“…Observing an ecological change like this is diffi cult on a coarse spatial scale. In particular, increases in shrub biomass caused by intensive grazing (Tobler et al, 2003;Laliberte et al, 2004), increases in the biomass of unpalatable plants, such as thorny shrubs and plants with prostrate growth forms (Nakamura et al, 2000;Wuyunna et al, 2004), increases in the biomass of xerophytic or halophytic plants (Kawanabe et al, 1998), and increases in the proportion of C 4 plants (Tsendeekhuu & Black, 2005) have been reported as signs of change.…”