The Impact of Cardiovascular Disease Prevalence on Women's Enrollment in Landmark Randomized Cardiovascular Trials: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Many studies have demonstrated that women are substantially underrepresented in cardiovascular trials, but few have considered that women develop cardiovascular disease at older ages than men. The extent to which observed gender enrollment inequalities persist after accounting for age-gender differences in disease prevalence is unknown. The purpose of the study was to compare observed rates of women participating in cardiovascular clinical trials with expected rates of female participation based on age-and gender-specific population disease prevalence. Publications between 1997 and 2009 in the three leading medical journals were included to calculate observed women's enrollment rates. Population-based data in Canada were used to determine the expected enrollment rates of women. Multicenter, randomized cardiovascular clinical trials that enrolled both men and women were analyzed. Two reviewers independently extracted data on women's enrollment and important clinical trial characteristics. The female enrollment rate was 30% in the included 325 trials, which ranged from 27% in trials of coronary artery disease, 27% in heart failure, 31% in arrhythmia, to 45% in primary prevention. Increased female enrollment correlated strongly with increasing age at recruitment in cardiovascular clinical trials (P< 0.001). After accounting for age-and gender-specific differences in disease prevalence, gaps in female enrollment were much lower than the expected enrollment rates estimated by 5% in coronary artery disease, 13% in heart failure, 9% in arrhythmia, and 3% in primary prevention. Only cardiovascular trials were evaluated in our study. Female underrepresentation in cardiovascular clinical trials is smaller than conventionally believed after accounting for age-and gender-specific population disease prevalence. Our findings suggest that greater representation of women in cardiovascular clinical trials can be achieved through the recruitment of older populations.

Guidelines for the Prevention of Stroke in Women

“…Stroke was not included in this analysis, however. 408 The percentage of women enrolled in recent stroke prevention trials of carotid disease and antiplatelet agents ranges from 25% to 53%, with an average of 34%, which is generally below the stroke prevalence rates by sex (Tables 14 and15).…”

Sex‐specific efficacy and safety of cryoballoon versus radiofrequency ablation for atrial fibrillation: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

“…The proportion of female patients enrolled in the clinical trials investigated in this meta‐analysis is consistent with the female enrollment observed in other cardiovascular trials, especially in the field of electrophysiology. Trials investigating arrhythmia and more particularly devices or interventions have been shown to be particularly prone to underenrollment of women . Several reasons have been suggested in previous literature.…”

Gender differences in clinical registration trials: is there a real problem?

“…cancer, vascular surgery and cardiovascular trials 9, 10, 11, 12, 13), with the general media continuing to report that large gender gaps are still putting women at a disadvantage 14. This reporting has had serious effects on policy, with large amounts of money being allocated to study gender differences in healthcare 15.…”