The impact of adult behavioural weight management interventions on mental health: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

Abstract

Summary There is good evidence that behavioural weight management interventions improve physical health; however, the impact on mental health remains unclear. We evaluated the impact of behavioural weight management interventions on mental health‐related outcomes in adults with overweight or obesity at intervention‐end and 12 months from baseline. Eligible studies were randomized controlled trials (RCTs) or cluster RCTs of adult behavioural weight loss interventions reporting affect, anxiety, binge eating, body image, depression, emotional eating, quality of life, self‐esteem and stress. We searched seven databases from inception to 7 May 2019 and included 43 articles reporting 42 RCTs. Eighteen studies were deemed to be at high risk of bias. We conducted random‐effects meta‐analyses, stratified analyses and meta‐regression using Stata. Interventions generated greater improvements than comparators for depression, mental health‐related quality of life and self‐efficacy at intervention‐end and 12 months from baseline. There was no difference between groups for anxiety, overall quality of life, self‐esteem or stress at intervention‐end. There was insufficient evidence to assess the impact on anxiety, binge eating, body image, emotional eating, affect, life satisfaction, self‐esteem or stress at intervention‐end and/or 12 months from baseline. Although evidence suggests that interventions benefit some aspects of mental health, high‐quality, transparently reported RCTs measuring a range of mental health outcomes over longer durations are required to strengthen the evidence base.

A systematic review of binge eating, loss of control eating, and weight loss in children and adolescents

“…Though concerns regarding promotion of diet culture in weight‐loss interventions have an important role in the discussion on weight management, these interventions that have been shown to improve general mood and decrease psychopathology are distinct from restrictive, disordered dieting that may be inaccurately associated with such therapies (70). This aligns with research in adults as well (71), as a recent meta‐analysis found an overall improvement in mental health outcomes following weight‐management interventions (72). However, the longest study to assess this issue was 2 years following treatment.…”

“…Adolescents may find it difficult to assess whether their food intake is objectively large, possibly leading to overreporting of OBEs (68). (72). However, the longest study to assess this issue was 2 years following treatment.…”

Microvascular Contribution to Late-Onset Depression: Mechanisms, Current Evidence, Association With Other Brain Diseases, and Therapeutic Perspectives

“…Microvascular dysfunction might be at least partly reversible through weight loss and exercise (23). Recent meta-analyses suggest that exercise and weight loss interventions have a beneficial effect on depressive symptoms across a wide age range, including older individuals (106,107). To what extent any effects of these interventions are mediated by improvement of microvascular function remains to be elucidated.…”

Is a Mediterranean Diet Associated with Subjective Well-Being among Adults with Overweight and Obesity? The Key Role of Fruit and Vegetable Consumption and Body Satisfaction

“…This study contributes to research on happiness and its correlates in obese individuals . While weight loss has been associated with some benefits in terms of mental health and psychological well-being (Jones et al, 2020), adhering to the MedDiet could become an ecological approach to improve the affective experience and life evaluation of the population, particularly individuals who are overweight and obese, entailing benefits for and beyond happiness. Public policy programs to encourage healthy eating can stress that happiness gains from healthy eating may occur much more quickly than any long-distance improvement to people's physical health (Conner et al, 2015(Conner et al, , 2017Ford et al, 2013;McMillan et al, 2011;Mujcic & Oswald, 2016;White et al, 2013).…”