The impact of a multidisciplinary small renal mass clinic on patient treatment decisions

Abstract

Introduction: Small renal masses (SRMs) are managed with active surveillance (AS), thermal ablation (TA), irreversible electroporation (IRE), or surgery, depending on patient and tumor factors. A novel SRM multidisciplinary clinic (SRMC), involving urologists and interventional radiologists, was established to provide patients with information on treatments options. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of the SRMC on treatment decision-making Methods: Demographics, tumor characteristics, and treatment decisions were prospectively collected on patients (n=216) attending the SRMC between 2016 and 2019. A retrospective historic cohort (n=238) seen by urologists was used as a control group. Key variables were analyzed and compared. Patient satisfaction (n=27) was surveyed and responses were summarized and explored. Results: Mean age, tumor size, and pathology was similar between groups; however, the SRMC cohort had more male patients (65.7% vs. 53.8%, p=0.009). Chosen treatment modality differed significantly between cohorts (p<0.0001). Patients in the historic cohort were treated by AS (41.5%), surgery (37.9%), TA (11.9%), watchful waiting (7.9%), and IRE (0.8%). SRMC patients were treated by TA (42.2%), AS (26.7%), surgery (21.3%), IRE (7.6%), and watchful waiting (2.2%). Post-hoc analysis revealed statistically significant differences in proportions of AS, TA, IRE, and surgery between cohorts. Patients reported high satisfaction with the collaborative approach. Conclusions: A multidisciplinary approach may have an impact on patient treatment decision-making for SRMs. Consultations involving a urologist and an interventional radiologist resulted in more TA and IRE and less AS and surgery. Future studies should evaluate if these findings occur in other centers.

Striving for consistent, multidisciplinary, evidence-based counselling for all patients

“…I n the study by Earis in this month's issue of CUAJ, patients with a small renal mass (SRM) attending a multidisciplinary clinic, comprised of a urologist and interventional radiologist, made different management choices than a historical cohort of patients primarily managed by a urologist alone. 1 Notably, almost 50% of patients in the multidisciplinary clinic cohort selected thermal ablation or irreversible electroporation therapy compared to 12.7% selecting these treatments historically. Consequently, the rate of active surveillance and surgery decreased for patients seen in the multidisciplinary clinic.…”