The present work
presents the first single-molecule fluorescence
resonant energy transfer (smFRET) studies of the nickel/cobalt (NiCo)
riboswitch, with temperature-dependent, single-molecule confocal microscopy
to provide comprehensive kinetic and thermodynamic information on
folding into a biochemically competent structure. The results indicate
that the NiCo riboswitch first folds into a more compact “prefolded”
conformation, with a preorganized binding pocket partially stabilized
under physiological conditions by noncognate monovalent/divalent cations.
Such a prefolded intermediate then has opportunity to fold further
into a tightly ligand-bound structure, in response to the cognate
ligands, Ni2+ or Co2+, with submicromolar affinities.
Such stepwise ligand-induced folding represents a particularly clean
example of a conformational selection (“fold-then-bind”)
mechanism, whereby a configuration dynamically accessible by thermal
fluctuation is stabilized into the final folded state by ligand association.
In addition, we observe a strong positive cooperativity in the ligand-induced
folding kinetics with respect to both Ni2+ and Co2+ ligands. This provides maximal sensitivity in the riboswitch conformational
response near [Ni2+] or [Co2+] ≈ K
d, which facilitates more accurate biochemical
probing of the cell environment and therefore bioregulation of gene
expression. Temperature-dependent kinetics at the single-molecule
level has also been explored, which permits free energies to be deconstructed
into enthalpic and entropic components along the folding coordinate.
In the absence of the cognate ligand, a predominantly enthalpic barrier
between the unfolded riboswitch (U) and the prefolded intermediate
(I) suggests a rearrangement of the hydrogen bonding network, whereas
in the presence of the cognate ligand, a large entropic penalty (−TΔS
0 > 0) in forming
the
folded riboswitch conformation (F) is almost perfectly counterbalanced
by an equivalent enthalpic gain (ΔH
0 < 0) to yield ΔG
0 ≈
0. The thermodynamic results are therefore consistent with a simple
physical picture of riboswitch folding, whereby association of the
cognate ligand is strongly stabilized by Coulombic attraction while
forming an entropically more ordered structure around the binding
site.