The hollow university: Disaster capitalism befalls American higher education

Abstract

Over the last 40 years, American institutions of higher education have been encouraged to align with the private sector by policymakers, think tank experts and businessmen in order to become more efficient and more accountable. In a wider sense, this new partnership may be evidence of what has been termed ''disaster capitalism.'' In disaster capitalism, crises are treated as economic opportunities. Governing bodies become ''hollow states'' which serve only to regulate contracts and provide further opportunities to entrepreneurs. The supposed crisis of accountability in American higher education may be such an opportunity. This paper argues for the emergence of the ''hollow university'' in American higher education. In the hollow university, state legislatures, think tank experts, leaders from the private sector and higher education administrators help to create a climate where institutions are more amendable to private sector partnerships. In order to determine this, I examine the desired inputs, processes, outputs and outcomes of four performance-based funding policies in the United States and demonstrate how the wording of these policies allow for and encourage private sector partnerships, specifically with emerging data companies such as Civitas Learning. Implications for the public mission of universities are discussed.

‘Pandemia’: a reckoning of UK universities’ corporate response to COVID-19 and its academic fallout

“…Relatedly, the effect of COVID-19 in accentuating the vulnerability of universities as public institutions operating within a quasi-market, may be seen to contribute to the 'hollowing-out' (Klein 2007) both of critical agency and solidarity among academic faculty, and of university leadership, subservient to, and shaped by the political and commercial interests of an antagonistic central government; and powerful transnational advocacy groups and for-profit entities (cf. Letizia 2016).…”

Derailed Values: Planning Education, External Funding, and Environmental Justice in New Orleans Rail Planning

“…Public money may support centers that bring together academics and industries, contributing to a “blurring of boundaries among markets, states and higher education” (Slaughter and Rhoades 2004, 11). Letizia (2016) has argued that crises in education funding 1 and university policies, including performance analytics, have made universities susceptible to pressures to align with the private sector. A new global university archetype has emerged, the global entrepreneurial university, with an emphasis on stronger internal collaboration and external relationships (Pinheiro and Stensaker 2014).…”