The Hierarchy of Controls as an Approach to Visualize the Impact of Occupational Safety and Health Coordination

Abstract

Occupational safety and health (OSH) in construction work continues to be a problematic issue, and OSH coordinators are a pivotal initiative for improving this in the EU. However, no studies on the impact of (OSH) coordinators in construction exists. This study conceptualizes the hierarchy of controls (HOC) as a means for visualizing and evaluating the impact of OSH coordinators’ work. The study engages with a large observational material based on fieldwork notes from 107 days of observations with 12 successful OSH coordinators. The analysis shows that during the 107 observation days, the coordinators implemented 280 OSH measures and were prevented 71 times from implementing measures. Most of the implemented measures were in the administrative (53.6%) and engineering (35%) controls. This may provide part of the explanation of why an increasing focus on OSH coordination has not translated into improved OSH outcomes in construction. The study contributes with insights for OSH coordinators and professionals seeking to improve the visibility and legitimacy of their work. In addition, it may be beneficial to organizations interested in ensuring the effectiveness of their organizational OSH practices. The study also creates foundations for more research-based practices, education, and professionalization of OSH coordinators as a profession.

Sustainability Assessment of Machinery Safety in a Manufacturing Organisation – Supporting Machinery Safety Decision Making with AHP and CART Methods

“…After consideration of the OHS by management and evaluation of all the proposed measures, it was found that in many cases they are repetitive and can be standardly divided into 7 basic types (see Table 15). All proposed measures represent some combination of the aforementioned measures and risk management hierarchy according to NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health) [39]. Two of them, i.e.…”

Risk Control of Construction Worker Hazards at Heights

“…Administrative control is a system of warnings, signals, signs, labels, instructions, training, education, or procedures to influence people's actions, reactions, or practices. This control includes the development of work methods and procedures, personnel selection, training, coaching, supervision, direction, planning, motivation, job rotation, change management, and changing or testing behavior, culture, or practice (Ajslev et al, 2022). Administrative control includes providing pre-employment and in-service training to all workers on covering workplace safety hazards and procedures, and most importantly, training on the importance of PPE use (Sehsah et al, 2020).…”

Determining the Effectiveness of Critical Controls in Construction Projects

“…The reliability of the control [barrier] is also a factor of the type of barrier being used and the interdependency on human action and the effectiveness of the safety management system supporting the reliability of the barrier [32]. The selection of barriers will apply the Hierarchy of Control as a means of reducing the risk of an event and improving the reliability of the barrier by selecting the most effective control type practicably available [33]. Controls related to hardware barriers (i.e.…”