The German Response to Kant's Essay on Perpetual Peace: Herder Contra the Romantics

Pizer, John

doi:10.3200/gerr.82.4.343-368

Cited by 3 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 8 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Fichte, Tieftrunk, Erhard), pero no dedica ningún apartado a Schlegel. Por su parte, Beiser (1990) y Pizer (2007) se ocupan de la recepción de Zum ewigen Frieden en el romanticismo alemán temprano. Por último, Garber (1980) y Fiorillo (2002) examinan este debate haciendo foco en la crítica democrática-radical de Bergk a la filosofía política kantiana.…”

unclassified

República y revolución: la crítica de Schlegel a Kant

Tomassini

2022

Isegoría

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

El propósito de este artículo es analizar la crítica de Schlegel a la filosofía política de Kant respecto de dos temas: el ideal republicano y la justificación de la revolución. En el Versuch, Schlegel vincula república y democracia y se opone a la tesis de Kant, según la cual la revolución no es moralmente permisible. La insurrección del pueblo es reivindicada como una forma de acción política autorizada por la voluntad general, con el fin de acelerar la institución de un régimen republicano. Mi argumento es que la postura de Schlegel respecto de la justificación de la revolución se apoya en dos pilares: primero, en una concepción rousseauniana del pueblo como poder constituyente y, segundo, en el rechazo de la doctrina kantiana acerca de la absoluta necesidad racional del Estado.

show abstract

unclassified

República y revolución: la crítica de Schlegel a Kant

Tomassini

2022

Isegoría

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Kant and Herder on colonialism, indigenous peoples, and minority nations

Spencer

2015

Int. Theory

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

It is the orthodox view in the cosmopolitan and normative international relations literature that Immanuel Kant is a staunch critic of European colonialism. This paper offers a far more critical stance towards Kant’s position with respect to minority nations and stateless Indigenous peoples through an analysis that draws on the criticisms developed by his contemporary and former student, Johann Gottfried Herder. The paper proceeds in three parts. In the first section, I present the evidence in favour of seeing both Kant and Herder as strident opponents of colonialism. In the second section, I then show the problems that arise in Kant’s position when his views on the state and property rights are taken into consideration. Kant’s coupling of the nation and state in contrast to Herder’s insistence that they are separate entities is highlighted as a crucial distinguishing point in their positions. In the third and final section, I indicate how Herder provides a far deeper critique of colonialism than Kant, also due to his recognition of the problematic nature of ideological pronouncements of progress.

show abstract

Johann Gottfried Herder on War and Peace

Laan

2009

Monatshefte

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The German Response to Kant's Essay on Perpetual Peace: Herder Contra the Romantics

Cited by 3 publications

References 8 publications

República y revolución: la crítica de Schlegel a Kant

República y revolución: la crítica de Schlegel a Kant

Kant and Herder on colonialism, indigenous peoples, and minority nations

Johann Gottfried Herder on War and Peace

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About