The geopolitics of COVID-19: US-China rivalry and the imminent Kindleberger trap

Abstract

Purpose The spread of COVID-19 is not just a health crisis. The pandemic has taken a geopolitical dimension. The health crisis amplified the competitive dynamics between the USA and China, affected the provision of global public goods and injected instability into the global order. In line with the geopolitical zero-sum thinking, both the USA and China have sought to capitalize on the crisis to boost their international profile. Instead of working together to mitigate the health and economic impacts of COVID-19, the two powers fear that the other will exploit the current situation to accrue political, economic or military gains that will give it an edge after the pandemic subsides. The spread of COVID-19 has set off a “battle of narratives,” in which China and the USA are accusing each other of failing to rise to the challenge. The world seems to be falling into a “Kindleberger Trap,” in which the established power is unable to lead while the rising power is unwilling to assume responsibility. The COVID-19 crisis is occurring amid the collapse of global cooperation. The USA, the traditional leader of international collective efforts in times of crisis, has abandoned its role entirely. The lack of leadership at the global level during an international crisis may cause the breakdown of the international order. Design/methodology/approach This paper examines the US-China competitive dynamics through the lens of the work of Charles Kindleberger, which both liberals and realists regard as foundational when examining the dynamics of global crisis management. This paper also uses the meta-geopolitics framework to determine the ability of both China and the USA to respond to the current COVID-19 crisis and its implications for their power and standing in the international system. Findings This paper concludes that the only way to escape the Kindleberger trap is “to embed Sino-American relations in multilateralism.” Originality/value As rivals, both the USA and China are seeking to capitalize on the crisis to boost their international profile. This paper probes how China and the USA navigated the ongoing COVID-19 crisis to determine whether or not they are currently in a “Kindleberger Trap,” using elements of the meta-geopolitics framework of analysis, namely, health issues, domestic politics, economics, science and international diplomacy. Using the meta-geopolitics framework will help us determine the ability of both China and the USA to respond to the current COVID-19 crisis and the implications of that on their power and standing in the international system.

Building a global community of health for all: A positive discourse analysis of COVID-19 discourse

“…As Frenk and Moon (2013) indicate, ‘Global governance is distinct from national governance in one critical respect: there is no government at the global level’ (p. 937). Bahi (2021) also states, ‘The lack of leadership at the global level during an international crisis may cause the breakdown of the international order’ (p. 76). The concept of building GCHA may provide a solution to improve the global health governance system.…”

Fractured Global Health Governance

“…The US-China rivalry during the pandemic is also framed by Riham Bahi (2021) in his writing entitled "The Geopolitics of COVID-19: US-China Rivalry and the Imminent Kindleberger Trap," which discusses the collapse of global cooperation amid the COVID-19 crisis. This paper also emphasizes that the US has left its role in leading international collective efforts amid the COVID-19 pandemic as a traditional leader.…”

“…This paper also emphasizes that the US has left its role in leading international collective efforts amid the COVID-19 pandemic as a traditional leader. During the crisis, the absence of leadership at the global level has led to the breakdown of the international order (Bahi, 2021).…”

COVID-19: A Game-changer to Equity Markets?

“…Apart from its medical complexities, the COVID-19 crisis has left us with ambiguities about its other impact dimensions. Thus far, studies have found that this global disruption has influenced several affairs with respect to the psychological well-being of people [1], environment [2], education [3] and geopolitics [4], to name a few.…”