The Gendered Culture of Scientific Competence: A Study of Scientist Characters in Doctor Who 1963–2013

Abstract

The present study examines the relationship between gender and scientific competence in fictional representations of scientists in the British science fiction television program Doctor Who. Previous studies of fictional scientists have argued that women are often depicted as less scientifically capable than men, but these have largely taken a simple demographic approach or focused exclusively on female scientist characters. By examining both male and female scientists (n = 222) depicted over the first 50 years of Doctor Who, our study shows that, although male scientists significantly outnumbered female scientists in all but the most recent decade, both genders have consistently been depicted as equally competent in scientific matters. However, an in-depth analysis of several characters depicted as extremely scientifically non-credible found that their behavior, appearance, and relations were universally marked by more subtle violations of gender expectations. Incompetent male scientists were largely depicted as effeminate and lacking in masculinity. In addition, many incompetent male and all incompetent female scientists served regimes that were problematically effeminate, collectivist and pacifist, or male-rejecting and ruled by women. Although Doctor Who avoids overtly treating women and men unequally, strong codes of masculine capability and prowess nevertheless continue to influence representations of scientific competence, pointing to the continued pervasiveness of such associations within wider Western culture. Professionals working to encourage gender-inclusive practices in science should look to subtle discourses about the masculine culture of science in addition to institutional and structural impediments to participation for women and gender minorities.

The Construction of Physics as a Quintessentially Masculine Subject: Young People’s Perceptions of Gender Issues in Access to Physics

“…You don’t really see many female ones anywhere” (Celina2, White English, F, social class 4). Such statements are supported by research analysis showing the associations between science competence and men/masculinity in the media (e.g., Orthia and Morgain 2016). Indeed, Archer et al (Archer and DeWitt 2014; Archer et al 2015) have catalogued in detail the exclusionary power of such imagery and its debilitating impact on the science aspirations of those not inhabiting the projected “appropriate body” (i.e., not male, middle class, and White/South or East Asian).…”

How does science fiction television shape fans' relationships to science? Results from a survey of 575 ‘Doctor Who’ viewers

“…Aside from the Doctor, the show has depicted hundreds of scientist characters over the years (including in applied sciences such as engineering, technology and medicine), some of whom became the Doctor's regular travelling companions. Scholars have discussed aspects of how all these characters are depicted, including their gendered and racialized dimensions [Coppa, 2010;Jowett, 2017;Orthia, 2010;Orthia and Morgain, 2016;Tulloch and Alvarado, 1983;Yeager, 2013] and how they conform to or challenge scientist stereotypes [Haynes, 2003;Jones, 1997;Orthia, 2011b;Roach, 2011]. These studies suggest Doctor Who is usually but not always pro-science in its depictions of scientist stereotypes.…”

“…These studies suggest Doctor Who is usually but not always pro-science in its depictions of scientist stereotypes. It also overtly opposes gender-and race-based discrimination, but its stories nonetheless often endorse problematic discourses such as a characterization of science as masculinist, or the imperialist deployment of a western scientific worldview [Morgain, 2013;Orthia, 2013;Orthia and Morgain, 2016].…”

A Research on the Change of Female Characters Portrayed in Science Fiction Films and Its Social Influences

“…Similarly, [3] point out that the performance of the female scientists in episodes will have a psychological impact on the audience's choice of career. Since scientists are widely depicted in sci-fi films, it is worthy of paying attention to that specific field of career.…”