The future of neurosurgery: a white paper on the recruitment and retention of women in neurosurgery

Abstract

Preface. The leadership of Women in Neurosurgery (WINS) has been asked by the Board of Directors of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS) to compose a white paper on the recruitment and retention of female neurosurgical residents and practitioners.Introduction. Neurosurgery must attract the best and the brightest. Women now constitute a larger percentage of medical school classes than men, representing approximately 60% of each graduating medical school class. Neurosurgery is facing a potential crisis in the US workforce pipeline, with the number of neurosurgeons in the US (per capita) decreasing.Women in the Neurosurgery Workforce. The number of women entering neurosurgery training programs and the number of board-certified female neurosurgeons is not increasing. Personal anecdotes demonstrating gender inequity abound among female neurosurgeons at every level of training and career development. Gender inequity exists in neurosurgery training programs, in the neurosurgery workplace, and within organized neurosurgery.Obstacles. The consistently low numbers of women in neurosurgery training programs and in the workplace results in a dearth of female role models for the mentoring of residents and junior faculty/practitioners. This lack of guidance contributes to perpetuation of barriers to women considering careers in neurosurgery, and to the lack of professional advancement experienced by women already in the field. There is ample evidence that mentors and role models play a critical role in the training and retention of women faculty within academic medicine. The absence of a critical mass of female neurosurgeons in academic medicine may serve as a deterrent to female medical students deciding whether or not to pursue careers in neurosurgery. There is limited exposure to neurosurgery during medical school. Medical students have concerns regarding gender inequities (acceptance into residency, salaries, promotion, and achieving leadership positions). Gender inequity in academic medicine is not unique to neurosurgery; nonetheless, promotion to full professor, to neurosurgery department chair, or to a national leadership position is exceedingly rare within neurosurgery. Bright, competent, committed female neurosurgeons exist in the workforce, yet they are not being promoted in numbers comparable to their male counterparts. No female neurosurgeon has ever been president of the AANS, Congress of Neurological Surgeons, or Society of Neurological Surgeons (SNS), or chair of the American Board of Neurological Surgery (ABNS). No female neurosurgeon has even been on the ABNS or the Neurological Surgery Residency Review Committee and, until this year, no more than 2 women have simultaneously been members of the SNS. Gender inequity serves as a barrier to the advancement of women within both academic and community-based neurosurgery.Strategic Approach to Address Issues Identified. To overcome the issues identified above, the authors recommend that the AANS join WINS in implementing a strategic plan, as foll...

Do Men Outperform Women During Orthopaedic Residency Training?

“…Similarly, the American Association of Neurological Surgeons has identified a major problem with recruitment of women into neurosurgery and cites obstacles such as the lack of a critical mass of female neurosurgeons in academic medicine to serve as role models, gender inequity for acceptance into residency, unfair treatment for promotion, and limited opportunities for advancement of their careers as female neurosurgeons [3]. Whether similar circumstances exist in the orthopaedic community bears scrutiny.…”

Bibliometric evaluation of pediatric neurosurgery in North America

“…Whatever the status quo, the specialty of pediatric neurosurgery must continue to foster a supportive environment for female academic surgeons and ensure that women are adequately represented in training and leadership positions, as recommended by the recent Women in Neurosurgery white paper. 2 …”

Gender Disparities in Scholarly Productivity within Academic Otolaryngology Departments

“…3,[7][8][9] In addition, women are underrepresented in academic practice within surgical specialties, including positions of leadership, such as departmental chair or division chief. 7,[10][11][12][13] There are several reasons for disparities in women participation in surgical specialties. Few senior female role models, lack of mentoring (formal or informal) by either men or women to young women considering surgical subspecialization, and concerns about work-life balance are major reasons.…”

“…22 Nearly one third of general surgery residents, 20% to 30% of plastic surgery residents, and 12% of neurological surgery residents are women. 3,4,10,[23][24][25] There has been a tripling of female otolaryngology residents from the early 1980s to 21% in 2003. 12,26 While women are still underrepresented in otolaryngology and other surgical specialties, they are even further underrepresented in positions of leadership; one recent analysis noted 4 of 103 academic otolaryngology departments had female chairs in 2011.…”