Rerezvvd 22Jub 199.3; acceptedfor pubhcatzon I6 September I994Drspitc a divcrsity of larval forms, remarkably c o n s c n 4 v c lcaturcs of astcroid dr\&~pmcnt dcfine a larval body plan that occurs throughout thr class. However, recent work on the starfish Plera.rter le.dalu.c has documented a highly derived pattern 0 1 development. Several features, including radial symmctry, parallcl cmbryonir and adult axes of symmetry, absence of a preoral lobe, and formation of corloms in the adult orientation from seven separate enterocoels, have not been reported in asteroids belore. 'l'he complete absence of the l a n d body plan features that are found in other asteroids, indicates that P. /uJJelafu.i dcvclops dircctly from thc cmbryo to thr juvcnilc and has a pelagic, nonfeeding (lecithotrophic), but nonlanal modc of dcvclopmcnt. I postulatc that dirrct dc\dopmcnt cvolvcd ovcr an rxtrndrd period in a lineage of brooding, deep-sea velatid (probably ptcrastcrid) anccstors of P. tenelalu.c. Selection for increased drvelopmental efficiency (loss of nonfunctional land fcaturrs) in the brooded offspring, could explain thr lack of larval settlement structurrs, thr nonlawal arrangement of coelonis, the lack of a prcoral lobc, thc lransvcrst' orirntation of the juvenile disc, and the lack of Idateral symmctry. T h c pattern of coclomogencsis could have been derived from that of othcr vclatids (c.g. solasterids) by relatively simple changes in timing and orientation of rntcmcocl formation, Rotation and posterior translation of the coelornic fate map of thc archcntrron prior to enterocoel formation would produce the coelomic compartments in the adult orirritation that rharactrrizes direct development in P. tesselatu. Thrsc unusual drvelopmrntal features lead to a radically different intcrprctation for the evolution of the pelagic 'larva' of P. lumlalus: ( I ) evolution of bcnthic brooding, (2) extreme simplification of development involving the loss of all l a n d features from thc life cycle, and (3) subsequent rervolution of pelagic development. In thc ( of P. k m l a l u h , where all larval structures were lost, thcrc do not serm to be functional constraints prcventing the re-evolution of prlagic developmrnt. Analysis of pelagic and benthic lamar, in other asteroids, suggests that major ccological transitions in lifr histories need not hc associated with substantial changes in moq)holocgygy. T h e loss of pelagic development should haw occurred repeatedly and should bc rcadily reversible. 'l'hese findings have interesting implications for the loss and evolution of pclagic disprrsal in the life histories of marine benthic invcrtcbrates.