The Flexible Governance of Water in Cairo’s Informal Areas

Abstract

This article explores the relationship between informality and water infrastructure in informal areas in Egypt. I apply three concepts drawn from the wider literatures on state power and governance: Topological power, flexible governing, and the "statization" of urban space. I find that infrastructure has functioned as one of the main instruments through which the state is produced or "effected" in the daily lives of residents. Due to this, examining the governance of water infrastructure in informal areas exposes the Egyptian state's "flexibility" and the uneven nature of its power. I argue that this flexibility is a result of the ad hoc nature of power in governance and the uneven quality of the state's authority and reach. This flexibility creates a waterscape constituted by overlapping infrastructures, practices, and actors, making traditional binaries such as public-private and formal-informal meaningless. However, I find that in Egypt's post-Arab-Spring era, the state has been seeking ways to effect its presence more strongly within informal areas, and one of the ways in which it has been doing so is by incorporating "informal" users into the "formal" public water supply and allowing/forcing them to pay for water. I argue that this accommodation of informality is a way to increase the statization of informal areas, while also charging them for water usage. In this way, I find that the state's flexibility allows it to benefit from informality without having to actually "formalise" the neighbourhoods themselves or address the underlying causes of why they are labelled as informal.

Factors associated with accessing and utilisation of healthcare and provision of health services for residents of slums in low and middle-income countries: a scoping review of recent literature

“…Previous studies have reported various risk factors affecting health of slum residents such as physical environment,6 sanitation,7 social capital8 9 and water governance,10 and have observed in some cases that slum residents have worse health status compared with non-slum urban and/or rural residents. For example, Ezeh et al found that children living in slums had higher mortality than rural and non-slum urban populations 3.…”

The De-territorialization on Egypt’s Desert Cities: The Case of Sixth of October City

“…Indeed, several studies have delved into the way residents have negotiated around these inequalities by working together to put alternative (often informal) mechanisms of access in place (cf. Bremer and Bhuiyan 2014;Khalil 2019). These ways of collectively navigating the city's management have been described by Simone (2004) as a form of 'people as infrastructure', such that city-dwellers come to rely on each other in the absence of state provision of basic services.…”

“…These ways of collectively navigating the city's management have been described by Simone (2004) as a form of 'people as infrastructure', such that city-dwellers come to rely on each other in the absence of state provision of basic services. As shown by Khalil (2019), this was for decades an important, if not primary, means of accessing basic services in many Egyptian cities.…”

Urban informality and the state: Repairing Cairo’s waters through Gehood Zateya

“…One important strategy adopted by the state in order to achieve further corporatization was the formalization of illegal settlements and the privatization of elite and middle-class housing. Although laws since the early 2000s stipulated that unplanned settlements should be upgraded (Khalil, 2019), it was only in 2008 that the Cairo governor conceded and endorsed the systemic installation of water piping in these areas 'regardless of their status' (Sims, 2012). These formalization strategies were important to place communities on the grid and render the city's waterscape legible.…”