Abstract:The radio and far-infrared luminosities of star-forming galaxies are tightly correlated over several orders of magnitude; this is known as the far-infrared radio correlation (FIRC). Previous studies have shown that a host of factors conspire to maintain a tight and linear FIRC, despite many models predicting deviation. This discrepancy between expectations and observations is concerning since a linear FIRC underpins the use of radio luminosity as a star-formation rate indicator. Using LOFAR 150 MHz, FIRST 1.4 … Show more
“…We notice immediately that, despite differences in the location of our sources on the FIRC compared to Ivison et al (2010) (likely due to our FIR estimation method and selection effects, as discussed below), none of our sources appear significantly below the FIRC, and therefore we may assume that our sources do not host radio-loud AGN, or at least that their spectra are dominated by contributions from star formation. Selecting only the brightest submillimetre sources from a flux-limited sample introduces selection effects such that we bias our sample towards the FIR-bright, radio-faint population; therefore, we do not attempt to comment on the distribution of our sources with regards to the normalisation of the FIRC and its dependence on other galaxy properties, such as redshift, temperature, and stellar mass, as extensively studied by, for example, Yun et al (2001), Ivison et al (2010), Smith et al (2014), andRead et al (2018). The depth of the radio surveys used in our sample also impacts the FIRC here: Many older studies are based on much shallower surveys, and the FIRC is plotted only for objects detected in both bands.…”
Section: The Far-infrared To Radio Correlation (Firc)mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Ramasawmy et al: Low-frequency radio spectra of submillimetre galaxies in the Lockman Hole Ivison et al 2010;Smith et al 2014). The Low Frequency Array (LOFAR; van Haarlem et al 2013) has opened up new ways of studying galaxies in the radio, and a number of studies have used LOFAR's capabilities to investigate this relationship between star formation and radio luminosity in the low-frequency regime -for example Gürkan et al (2018), Read et al (2018), Smith et al (2020), andWang et al (2019a). However, these studies generally investigate the statistical properties of large samples of galaxies, in optically selected samples at low redshift (z 2), rather than probing the shapes of individual radio spectra.…”
Aims. We investigate the radio properties of a sample of 850 μm-selected sources from the SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey (S2CLS) using new deep, low-frequency radio imaging of the Lockman Hole field from the Low Frequency Array. This sample consists of 53 sources, 41 of which are detected at >5σ at 150 MHz.
Methods. Combining these data with additional observations at 324 MHz, 610 MHz, and 1.4 GHz from the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the Jansky Very Large Array, we find a variety of radio spectral shapes and luminosities (L1.4 GHz ranging from ~4 × 1023−1 × 1025) within our sample despite their similarly bright submillimetre flux densities (>4 mJy). We characterise their spectral shapes in terms of multi-band radio spectral indices. Finding strong spectral flattening at low frequencies in ~20% of sources, we investigate the differences between sources with extremely flat low-frequency spectra and those with ‘normal’ radio spectral indices (α > −0.25).
Results. As there are no other statistically significant differences between the two subgroups of our sample as split by the radio spectral index, we suggest that any differences are undetectable in galaxy-averaged properties that we can observe with our unresolved images, and likely relate to galaxy properties that we cannot resolve, on scales ≲1 kpc. We attribute the observed spectral flattening in the radio to free–free absorption, proposing that those sources with significant low-frequency spectral flattening have a clumpy distribution of star-forming gas. We estimate an average spatial extent of absorbing material of at most several hundred parsecs to produce the levels of absorption observed in the radio spectra. This estimate is consistent with the highest-resolution observations of submillimetre galaxies in the literature, which find examples of non-uniform dust distributions on scales of ~100 pc, with evidence for clumps and knots in the interstellar medium. Additionally, we find two bright (>6 mJy) S2CLS sources undetected at all other wavelengths. We speculate that these objects may be very high redshift sources, likely residing at z > 4.
“…We notice immediately that, despite differences in the location of our sources on the FIRC compared to Ivison et al (2010) (likely due to our FIR estimation method and selection effects, as discussed below), none of our sources appear significantly below the FIRC, and therefore we may assume that our sources do not host radio-loud AGN, or at least that their spectra are dominated by contributions from star formation. Selecting only the brightest submillimetre sources from a flux-limited sample introduces selection effects such that we bias our sample towards the FIR-bright, radio-faint population; therefore, we do not attempt to comment on the distribution of our sources with regards to the normalisation of the FIRC and its dependence on other galaxy properties, such as redshift, temperature, and stellar mass, as extensively studied by, for example, Yun et al (2001), Ivison et al (2010), Smith et al (2014), andRead et al (2018). The depth of the radio surveys used in our sample also impacts the FIRC here: Many older studies are based on much shallower surveys, and the FIRC is plotted only for objects detected in both bands.…”
Section: The Far-infrared To Radio Correlation (Firc)mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Ramasawmy et al: Low-frequency radio spectra of submillimetre galaxies in the Lockman Hole Ivison et al 2010;Smith et al 2014). The Low Frequency Array (LOFAR; van Haarlem et al 2013) has opened up new ways of studying galaxies in the radio, and a number of studies have used LOFAR's capabilities to investigate this relationship between star formation and radio luminosity in the low-frequency regime -for example Gürkan et al (2018), Read et al (2018), Smith et al (2020), andWang et al (2019a). However, these studies generally investigate the statistical properties of large samples of galaxies, in optically selected samples at low redshift (z 2), rather than probing the shapes of individual radio spectra.…”
Aims. We investigate the radio properties of a sample of 850 μm-selected sources from the SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey (S2CLS) using new deep, low-frequency radio imaging of the Lockman Hole field from the Low Frequency Array. This sample consists of 53 sources, 41 of which are detected at >5σ at 150 MHz.
Methods. Combining these data with additional observations at 324 MHz, 610 MHz, and 1.4 GHz from the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope and the Jansky Very Large Array, we find a variety of radio spectral shapes and luminosities (L1.4 GHz ranging from ~4 × 1023−1 × 1025) within our sample despite their similarly bright submillimetre flux densities (>4 mJy). We characterise their spectral shapes in terms of multi-band radio spectral indices. Finding strong spectral flattening at low frequencies in ~20% of sources, we investigate the differences between sources with extremely flat low-frequency spectra and those with ‘normal’ radio spectral indices (α > −0.25).
Results. As there are no other statistically significant differences between the two subgroups of our sample as split by the radio spectral index, we suggest that any differences are undetectable in galaxy-averaged properties that we can observe with our unresolved images, and likely relate to galaxy properties that we cannot resolve, on scales ≲1 kpc. We attribute the observed spectral flattening in the radio to free–free absorption, proposing that those sources with significant low-frequency spectral flattening have a clumpy distribution of star-forming gas. We estimate an average spatial extent of absorbing material of at most several hundred parsecs to produce the levels of absorption observed in the radio spectra. This estimate is consistent with the highest-resolution observations of submillimetre galaxies in the literature, which find examples of non-uniform dust distributions on scales of ~100 pc, with evidence for clumps and knots in the interstellar medium. Additionally, we find two bright (>6 mJy) S2CLS sources undetected at all other wavelengths. We speculate that these objects may be very high redshift sources, likely residing at z > 4.
“…Recently, Gürkan et al (2018) investigated the low-frequency radio luminosity to star formation rate relation and far-IR to radio correlation (FIRC) in local star-forming galaxies selected based on their optical emission lines, using LOFAR-144 MHz measurements to probe radio and Herschel-250 µm to probe farIR. Read et al (2018) further used the same sample to investigate FIRC as a function of redshift, effective dust temperature, stellar mass, specific star formation rate, and mid-infrared colour. In Fig.…”
Section: What Is the Source Of Radio Emission In Quasars?mentioning
The radio-loud/radio-quiet (RL/RQ) dichotomy in quasars is still an open question. Although it is thought that accretion onto supermassive black holes in the centre the host galaxies of quasars is responsible for some radio continuum emission, there is still a debate as to whether star formation or active galactic nuclei (AGN) activity dominate the radio continuum luminosity. To date, radio emission in quasars has been investigated almost exclusively using high-frequency observations in which the Doppler boosting might have an important effect on the measured radio luminosity, whereas extended structures, best observed at low radio frequencies, are not affected by the Doppler enhancement. We used a sample of quasars selected by their optical spectra in conjunction with sensitive and high-resolution low-frequency radio data provided by the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) as part of the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) to investigate their radio properties using the radio loudness parameter (R =L144 MHz/Li band). The examination of the radio continuum emission and RL/RQ dichotomy in quasars exhibits that quasars show a wide continuum of radio properties (i.e. no clear bimodality in the distribution of ℛ). Radio continuum emission at low frequencies in low-luminosity quasars is consistent with being dominated by star formation. We see a significant albeit weak dependency of ℛ on the source nuclear parameters. For the first time, we are able to resolve radio morphologies of a considerable number of quasars. All these crucial results highlight the impact of the deep and high-resolution low-frequency radio surveys that foreshadow the compelling science cases for the Square Kilometre Array (SKA).
“…Whatever the origin of the emission, properly characterizing the radio-quiet population is critical for understanding the connection between quasar outflows and star formation. In addition, the well-known correlation between far-infrared luminosity and radio luminosity, the far-infrared radio correlation (Helou, Soifer & Rowan-Robinson 1985;Yun, Reddy & Condon 2001;Calistro Rivera et al 2017;Gürkan et al 2018;Read et al 2018) means that radio luminosity can be used as a star formation rate estimator in certain cases; understanding the level at which this correlation is contaminated from AGN-driven mechanisms is again important.…”
We present an investigation of the low-frequency radio and ultraviolet properties of a sample of ≃10 500 quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 14, observed as part of the first data release of the Low-Frequency-Array (LOFAR) Two-metre Sky Survey. The quasars have redshifts 1.5 < z < 3.5 and luminosities 44.6 < log10(Lbol/erg s−1) < 47.2. We employ ultraviolet spectral reconstructions based on an independent component analysis to parametrize the C ivλ1549-emission line which is used to infer the strength of accretion disc winds, and the He ii λ1640 line, an indicator of the soft X-ray flux. We find that radio-detected quasars are found in the same region of C iv blueshift versus equivalent-width space as radio-undetected quasars, but that the loudest, most luminous and largest radio sources exist preferentially at low C iv blueshifts. Additionally, the radio-detection fraction increases with blueshift whereas the radio-loud fraction decreases. In the radio-quiet population, we observe a range of He ii equivalent widths as well as a Baldwin effect with bolometric luminosity, whilst the radio-loud population has mostly strong He ii, consistent with a stronger soft X-ray flux. The presence of strong He ii is a necessary but not sufficient condition to detect radio-loud emission suggesting some degree of stochasticity in jet formation. Using energetic arguments and Monte Carlo simulations, we explore the plausibility of winds, compact jets and star formation as sources of the radio quiet emission, ruling out none. The existence of quasars with similar ultraviolet properties but differing radio properties suggests, perhaps, that the radio and ultraviolet emission is tracing activity occurring on different timescales.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.