The Evidence-base for Using Ontologies and Semantic Integration Methodologies to Support Integrated Chronic Disease Management in Primary and Ambulatory Care: Realist Review

Abstract

SummaryBackground: Most chronic diseases are managed in primary and ambulatory care. The chronic care model (CCM) suggests a wide range of community, technological, team and patient factors contribute to effective chronic disease management. Ontologies have the capability to enable formalised linkage of heterogeneous data sources as might be found across the elements of the CCM. Objective: To describe the evidence base for using ontologies and other semantic integration methods to support chronic disease management. Method: We reviewed the evidence-base for the use of ontologies and other semantic integration methods within and across the elements of the CCM. We report them using a realist review describing the context in which the mechanism was applied, and any outcome measures. Results: Most evidence was descriptive with an almost complete absence of empirical research and important gaps in the evidence-base. We found some use of ontologies and semantic integration methods for community support of the medical home and for care in the community. Ubiquitous information technology (IT) and other IT tools were deployed to support self-management support, use of shared registries, health behavioural models and knowledge discovery tools to improve delivery system design. Data quality issues restricted the use of clinical data; however there was an increased use of interoperable data and health system integration. Conclusions: Ontologies and semantic integration methods are emergent with limited evidence-base for their implementation. However, they have the potential to integrate the disparate community wide data sources to provide the information necessary for effective chronic disease management.

An algorithm to improve diagnostic accuracy in diabetes in computerised problem orientated medical records (POMR) compared with an established algorithm developed in episode orientated records (EOMR)

“…We need to develop more formalised ways of developing and sharing algorithms and ontologies to sort complex datasets 29,30. The aggregation of increasingly large datasets raises issues of semantic interoperability and a need for automated methods to assess and manage data quality 30…”

Connected health and integrated care: Toward new models for chronic disease management

“…3, suggests that each individual should be represented by a series of hierarchically related entities and contain different data types, including discrete single-valued data, signals, annotations, etc., potentially originating from various sensors systems. Semantic technologies are typically employed in order to unambiguously express these sophisticated data models and support data validation and sharing [25].…”

In this issue: Ontologies a key concept in informatics and key for open definitions of cases, exposures, and outcome measures

“…This assertion is based on a realist review of the literature3 and an exploration of how this approach might lead to a more explicitly defined datasets when using routine data for chronic disease management,4 integrated care5,6 and vaccine benefit–risk research 7…”